Exhibition standards

Started by Newportnobby, Yesterday at 12:39:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Greygreaser, Southerngooner and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Newportnobby

Quote from: njee20 on <strong>Today</strong> at 12:12:13 PMI don't literally read that comment as "everything must be made of one material", of course you may use cardboard platforms, with 3D printed telegraph poles and styrene buildings. But to me it does look incongruous when you have some Metcalf buildings alongside some styrene ones, with a Lyddle End resin one there as well. It's not about actual finish per se. I'm sure they can be blended together satisfactorily such that no one item sticks out.

Agreed. But at the end of the day it's an exhibition manager's beady eye deciding whether it will appeal to the public assuming, of course, they have seen pics which they should have requested if not having seen a layout 'in the flesh'

thebrighton

Quote from: PLD on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:27:51 AMA place for a well thought out, well presented, well operated "starter" layout using readily available off the shelf materials showing what is achievable by the beginner - absolutely...  :thumbsup:
Deliberately making something run poorly or deliberately operating badly - definitely NO...  :thumbsdown:

Where did I say "deliberately"? I was just suggesting that if you see it can go wrong at an exhibition just like it can at home it may stop people loosing heart.

thebrighton

Quote from: Newportnobby on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:39:03 AMThe average punter would not take a layout to be shown off at an exhibition. I'm really not referring to Joe Bloggs with his fiddle yard to terminus layout but model railway clubs letting poorly presented large layouts to the paying public.
Sorry, Gareth, but it's a bit like entering a car into a Concours D'Elegance with it covered in dirt

And I wasn't referring to model railway clubs. Plenty of small exhibitions around here where (maybe club members) bring their own layout along.
No idea why you feel the need for the last sentence. Totally irrelevant. There are exhibitions for all levels some of which won't meet your expectations but will meet those of many others
It looks to me this is becoming elitist so I will leave this thread and wish I'd never bothered joining in.

PLD

Quote from: Greygreaser on <strong>Today</strong> at 11:47:44 AM
QuoteFinally the overall standard of the modelling. Here we're actually looking for consistency such that everything fits and gels together. for example Buildings of the same material (Metcalfe card kits are ok, but then use only card kits and don't mix with plastic kits). Generally the "Consistently Average" works better here than the "Outstanding in Parts/mediocre in others"...

Definitely don't agree with your final paragraph as the real world has buildings in many differing types of material. Each should suit the placement in the scenery and be suitably 'bashed' or weathered to be realistic modelling. Part of my 'trainset' critique of layouts is the adherence to multiples of the same components, kits or features.

The base material of card, plastics, plaster, resin etc should be irrelevant. If I went total card there's not enough red or yellow brick stuff to complete the modelling of East Anglia, let alone pink Suffolk cottages!
maybe could have worded a bit clearer...
If you have a street of 4 brick-built houses, if they're all plastic kits or all card kits, they present a consistent and coherent whole.
If you have 3 of one and an odd one of the other it stands out like a sore thumb...
Hull Model Railway Show: 5 & 6  June 2027
https://hullmodelrailwayshow.blogspot.com

EtchedPixels

Quote from: Newportnobby on <strong>Today</strong> at 12:24:14 PMAgreed. But at the end of the day it's an exhibition manager's beady eye deciding whether it will appeal to the public assuming, of course, they have seen pics which they should have requested if not having seen a layout 'in the flesh'

The exhibition managers beady eye is firmly on the exhibition managers budget for bigger shows. Can it be operated by less people, does it take a lot of space for only one set of sandwiches etc.

I'm also entertained by the idea it's all about the quality of the modelling as perceived by some high and mighty rivet counter in the sky who decides what model houses look next to one another. Many of the really interesting exhibition layouts are far from that - but they have things happening, they have atmosphere (which is not the same as rivet counts), or they are just fun - like some of the historical train set stuff.
"Knowledge has no value or use for the solitary owner: to be enjoyed it must be communicated" -- Charles Pratt, 1st Earl Camden

EtchedPixels

Quote from: chrism on <strong>Today</strong> at 08:33:32 AM
Quote from: GrahamB on <strong>Today</strong> at 08:15:36 AMEven worse because people can simply buy the stickers and fit them without performing any basic checks.

Since, in most cases, the basic checks involve checking that a wallwart case is not broken, a cable is not loose nor damaged and that a plug is not broken and contains the correct fuse, most of that would be seen when applying a label.

QuoteRemember dodgy MoT's from the pub around the corner?

Not really the same thing.

Frequently is these days. The utter lack of enforcement by professional bodies is becoming a very hot topic and it's a lot worse than dodgy PAT stickers. The current world of EICRs over the phone, non enforcement, no building inspectors and the like is going to end up in a catastrophic event at some point.

So I'd say it's very much the same thing as the MoT stuff although probably it's not going to be a model railway exhibition where it goes to pot.
"Knowledge has no value or use for the solitary owner: to be enjoyed it must be communicated" -- Charles Pratt, 1st Earl Camden

EtchedPixels

Quote from: Bealman on <strong>Today</strong> at 12:20:49 PMTo me the blending of various kits is more of a scale thing. To my eyes, Metcalf buildings appear to be to a larger scale than Kestrel plastic ones, for example.

Yes - Metcalfe appears to be sized to work with toy cars as well as down to N scale whilst Kestrel is on the small side. I find it really useful for perspective sometimes - even 1:160 or 1:200 architectural can look right in the back scene area.

"Knowledge has no value or use for the solitary owner: to be enjoyed it must be communicated" -- Charles Pratt, 1st Earl Camden

Southerngooner

When I first got into modelling in the early 70's I went to a lot of shows and took it all in. I can remember some layouts but most vanish into obscurity. "Exhibition standard" modelling seemed to be those like George Iliffe Stokes and others who could make (or have made) immaculate models that were very close to the prototype. At that time the thought that I'd ever be out there doing the exhibiting (albeit only as part of a team, but who knows, BL may get out soon...) couldn't be further from my mind. The first few shows I ever did as an operator were relatively small ones and I soon got used to the rhythm of a show - drive there, wait, set up, go to the pub - on set up day, and in reverse but with no pub on the last day. I love doing it, but it's not always sweetness and light. Chatting to the public and trying to assure them that none of us are "supermen" modellers, just normal people who have learnt some skills over the years.

The biggest difference from the 70's for me is the rise of the micro layout. GW branch terminii were prevalent in the 70's, and now it seems to be tiny portions of the real railway. These often photograph well and probably inspire people, but to watch they don't offer much of an experience. Most shows I've been to since 2014 have been two day affairs, and the quality is as mixed as ever. Some wonderful layouts are let down by poor running, and some poorly sceniced or unbelievably built (I'm a civil engineer so bad bridges, tunnels, etc make me cringe) run very well and have something about them that is soothing to the eye.

I am with @Newportnobby on the issue of club layouts. So many are let down by "lowest common denominator" modelling, but may inspire someone to try harder. I don't subscribe to the "that's too good/elitist for me" comments you sometimes see or hear though. It's a fact of life some people will be better at things that others, and in a club, with the right members and leadership, great things can happen. With the wrong people in charge and members of lesser standards who have not been taught/aided/inspired to do better, layouts can be very poor. Keeping something running must be a key factor, but not the same train all day long.

On the whole I'm glad we have exhibitions and will visit any in can within reasonable distance, as long as I'm available, and can usually find something positive at any show. 

Dave
Dave

Builder of "Brickmakers Lane" and member of "James Street" operating team.

Greygreaser

Re: club layouts - I visited a club which was very 'active' according to their website and news items, promoting MR yearly with an exhibition. Didn't join because it seemed to be over-organised with committee and sub-groups who potentially spent more time compromising than modelling. In one night of 3 hours there was diddly squat done on the layouts, much discussion and lots tea drunk.
On that observation it seems unlikely any club layout would ever be truly finished or operable by any member who volunteered for exhibition duty. Sadly this seems to appear sometimes at exhibitions and many of the highly praised layouts are from individuals rather than clubs.
A jack of all trades is a master of none, but often times better than a master of one.

Please Support Us!
November Goal: £100.00
Due Date: Nov 30
Total Receipts: £45.00
Below Goal: £55.00
Site Currency: GBP
45% 
November Donations