Exhibition standards

Started by Newportnobby, Yesterday at 12:39:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

thebrighton, Ensign Elliott, njee20 and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

chrism

Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 07:46:40 PM6. Make sure your electrics are PAT tested - its a pretty much universal requirement these days. Many exhibitions don't check for PAT labels as you set up but one day they will....

They can check - but as there is no legal requirement for labels they may not find any.
Likewise there is no legal requirement for any test to be performed by an electrician, just a competent person to check that wires/cables/plugs are secure and undamaged and that fuses, where fitted, are correct.



ntpntpntp

I used to have my gear PAT tested by an electrician friend, all properly labelled and logged.  The last time was 20 years ago though.   
Nick.   2026 celebrating the 30th anniversary of "Königshafen" exhibition layout!
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=50050.0

GrahamB

Quote from: chrism on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 08:30:43 PM
Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 07:46:40 PM6. Make sure your electrics are PAT tested - its a pretty much universal requirement these days. Many exhibitions don't check for PAT labels as you set up but one day they will....

They can check - but as there is no legal requirement for labels they may not find any.
Likewise there is no legal requirement for any test to be performed by an electrician, just a competent person to check that wires/cables/plugs are secure and undamaged and that fuses, where fitted, are correct.

Even worse, PAT stickers are freely available on a well known website. Even if a PAT sticker is legitimate, it only means the item was fit on the day it was tested.
Tonbridge MRC Member.
My Southwark Bridge thread can be found at https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=38683.0
My Southwark Bridge website can be found at https://southwarkbridge.wixsite.com/ngauge

GlenEglise

I have to say that overall Exhibition Layouts in Scotland are nowadays vastly improved over those of ten or twenty years ago.

From my experience in attending at least twelve shows a year with the N Gauge Society Forth & Clyde Area Group I think most N Gauge layouts I have seen are well presented and have trains running. The odd exception can be down to poor connectivity of modules or misalignments due to temperature differences, something Scotland has to deal with especially at Irvine in January!

Sometimes the main offenders are those in other scales and especially those layouts which employ very high tech wifi equipment. This is not a bad thing in itself but its use has to fit the locations abilities to support it.

Overall, I forgive some relatively poor layouts as I know how precious it is to people to devote their time to exhibiting in the first place and trying to promote N Gauge.

There is room for improvement but perhaps encouragement and assistance where needed would be more appropriate than pure criticism.

Tin Hat now ON!

GE

Will_J

Quote from: GlenEglise on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 10:32:50 PMSometimes the main offenders are those in other scales and especially those layouts which employ very high tech wifi equipment. This is not a bad thing in itself but its use has to fit the locations abilities to support it.

This is definitely something that layout operators need to be aware of with WiFi systems. It doesn't need an internet connection, however with so many phones nearby, it's very easy for many WiFi command stations to be overwhelmed by so many devices picking up the network even if they don't attempt to connect to it.

A good quality wireless router is essential for some systems to perform at their best. This is still a fairly new frontier in the hobby (though about ten years later than other hobbies using similar technology!) so hopefully in time it'll be less of a problem.

If I'm going to get a small layout done for Model World Live 2027 I'll have to sort one out for my DCC-EX system.

Will.

chrism

Quote from: GrahamB on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 09:13:54 PMEven worse, PAT stickers are freely available on a well known website.

What makes that "even worse"?
Since there is no requirement in the UK for the person performing the test inspection to be qualified in any way, there is no reason for the sale of stickers/labels to be restricted.

QuoteEven if a PAT sticker is legitimate, it only means the item was fit on the day it was tested.

Very true.

GrahamB

Quote from: chrism on <strong>Today</strong> at 07:17:28 AM
Quote from: GrahamB on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 09:13:54 PMEven worse, PAT stickers are freely available on a well known website.

What makes that "even worse"?
Since there is no requirement in the UK for the person performing the test inspection to be qualified in any way, there is no reason for the sale of stickers/labels to be restricted.

QuoteEven if a PAT sticker is legitimate, it only means the item was fit on the day it was tested.

Very true.

Even worse because people can simply buy the stickers and fit them without performing any basic checks. Remember dodgy MoT's from the pub around the corner?
Tonbridge MRC Member.
My Southwark Bridge thread can be found at https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=38683.0
My Southwark Bridge website can be found at https://southwarkbridge.wixsite.com/ngauge

chrism

Quote from: GrahamB on <strong>Today</strong> at 08:15:36 AMEven worse because people can simply buy the stickers and fit them without performing any basic checks.

Since, in most cases, the basic checks involve checking that a wallwart case is not broken, a cable is not loose nor damaged and that a plug is not broken and contains the correct fuse, most of that would be seen when applying a label.

QuoteRemember dodgy MoT's from the pub around the corner?

Not really the same thing.


thebrighton

Although I would rather see quality layouts working faultlessly to play devils advocate I believe there is a place for layouts of "poorer" quality with poor running.

The average punter at exhibitions may well have a layout at home like that or is looking to get into the hobby.

If all exhibition layouts were perfect it could be very demoralising for the average Joe. Sure, perfection can be something for them to aspire to but they could be at the point of giving up but when they see something at an exhibition that mirrors their own or something they feel they can achieve when starting out it could well be the thing that keeps them in the hobby.

The hobby covers a big demographic, a wide spread of ability and ambition.

PLD

Quote from: thebrighton on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:12:52 AMAlthough I would rather see quality layouts working faultlessly to play devils advocate I believe there is a place for layouts of "poorer" quality with poor running.
A place for a well thought out, well presented, well operated "starter" layout using readily available off the shelf materials showing what is achievable by the beginner - absolutely...  :thumbsup:
Deliberately making something run poorly or deliberately operating badly - definitely NO...  :thumbsdown:
Hull Model Railway Show: 5 & 6  June 2027
https://hullmodelrailwayshow.blogspot.com

Newportnobby

Quote from: thebrighton on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:12:52 AMI believe there is a place for layouts of "poorer" quality with poor running.

The average punter at exhibitions may well have a layout at home like that or is looking to get into the hobby.


The average punter would not take a layout to be shown off at an exhibition. I'm really not referring to Joe Bloggs with his fiddle yard to terminus layout but model railway clubs letting poorly presented large layouts to the paying public.
Sorry, Gareth, but it's a bit like entering a car into a Concours D'Elegance with it covered in dirt

Roy L S

Quote from: Newportnobby on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:39:03 AM
Quote from: thebrighton on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:12:52 AMI believe there is a place for layouts of "poorer" quality with poor running.

The average punter at exhibitions may well have a layout at home like that or is looking to get into the hobby.


The average punter would not take a layout to be shown off at an exhibition. I'm really not referring to Joe Bloggs with his fiddle yard to terminus layout but model railway clubs letting poorly presented large layouts to the paying public.
Sorry, Gareth, but it's a bit like entering a car into a Concours D'Elegance with it covered in dirt

Agreed, people pay to go to a model railway exhibition and it is therefore a reasonable expectation that they will see layouts that look good and run to a standard that isn't completely cringeworthy (constant stalling, "had of God" prodding etc). That is not to say that every layout has to use finescale track and be an electronics marvel, I have seen plenty that show what a modeller without years of acquired knowledge and modelling expertise can do using commercially available parts to very good effect.

A pet hate of mine is overused lighting effects and in particular the "fairground" type scenes, but each to their own...

Roy

Greygreaser

QuoteFinally the overall standard of the modelling. Here we're actually looking for consistency such that everything fits and gels together. for example Buildings of the same material (Metcalfe card kits are ok, but then use only card kits and don't mix with plastic kits). Generally the "Consistently Average" works better here than the "Outstanding in Parts/mediocre in others"...

Definitely don't agree with your final paragraph as the real world has buildings in many differing types of material. Each should suit the placement in the scenery and be suitably 'bashed' or weathered to be realistic modelling. Part of my 'trainset' critique of layouts is the adherence to multiples of the same components, kits or features.

The base material of card, plastics, plaster, resin etc should be irrelevant. If I went total card there's not enough red or yellow brick stuff to complete the modelling of East Anglia, let alone pink Suffolk cottages!

Other contributing items like telegraph poles, fencing, hedges, trees and surface textures inevitably come in a wide variety of base materials as do specialist kits where brass etchings contribute.

My view is - does it appeal rather than appal me when I view it?
A jack of all trades is a master of none, but often times better than a master of one.

njee20

I don't literally read that comment as "everything must be made of one material", of course you may use cardboard platforms, with 3D printed telegraph poles and styrene buildings. But to me it does look incongruous when you have some Metcalf buildings alongside some styrene ones, with a Lyddle End resin one there as well. It's not about actual finish per se. I'm sure they can be blended together satisfactorily such that no one item sticks out.

Bealman

To me the blending of various kits is more of a scale thing. To my eyes, Metcalf buildings appear to be to a larger scale than Kestrel plastic ones, for example.
Vision over visibility. Bono, U2.

Please Support Us!
November Goal: £100.00
Due Date: Nov 30
Total Receipts: £45.00
Below Goal: £55.00
Site Currency: GBP
45% 
November Donations