Which Drill ?

Started by upnick, January 25, 2013, 01:42:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

upnick

Hi  All,   

After 6  years service it seems either the battery or charger is on it's way out on  my Bosch  9.6V cordless drill,   i  have an  electric  drill  for when  it,s along job  but the cordless is brilliant for general  use.

My question  is  while i'm  contemplating  buying  battery /charger i  might as well get a fresh drill   which  seems to  be 14.4V   average, any reccomendations for a good one  not just  with the price in mind &  where to get  it   ........ if memory serves me right this one was  £40  &  came with a pack  of bits

The old one  might be useful   to  someone  as it's in  fair condition  so  i  can recoup some of the cost ?   

Bikeracer

I bought one of these and it seems to be a really good tool,it's got lithium batteries which quick charge and what I really like about it is the small size and light weight.
It felt strange at first having no heavy battery stuck on the end to get in the way but it really is comfortable to use and the small size means you can get in places the normal battery drill won't fit.

I used mine to build my layout and I've never regretted buying it.

http://www.screwfix.com/p/erbauer-erp223ddh-10-8v-1-3ah-li-ion-cordless-drill-driver/52782

Allan
I'm not a complete idiot..some bits are missing.

scotsoft

Since it is a Bosch, I would imagine you should be able to get a new battery for it and I would bet it is the battery since you have had it six years, you can only charge them so often.

If you are going ahead with a new drill it seems logical to stick with Bosch since you have had good service from your now deceased one RIP.

cheers John.

saddler

i sold a dead bosch 9.6v with 2 dead batteries and charger on ebay for £25 recently, being good quality people will buy to refurbish so you should get a bit towards a new one, i only tend to buy dewalt or makita tools lately but for general use can highly recomend the erbauer tools from screwfix, good prices and you usually get two batteries :D

Newportnobby

Quote from: scotsoft on January 25, 2013, 01:57:25 PM
Since it is a Bosch, I would imagine you should be able to get a new battery for it and I would bet it is the battery since you have had it six years, you can only charge them so often.

If you are going ahead with a new drill it seems logical to stick with Bosch since you have had good service from your now deceased one RIP.

cheers John.
Not necessarily so, John. I had a Bosch cordless for a long time and, like Upnicks, the battery wouldn't charge. When I tried to source a replacement battery I was told they had amended the spec and the old ones were no longer available.
Having liked the Bosch, I bought a new cordless with twin batteries in a neat case from a well known DIY store as they were on offer at about £55. This one also has a small light in case I need to make holes in the dark ;)

REGP

Strangely enough my own cordless drill (a Boch 14.4 voltage) gave up the ghost this week when I was trying to fit a drop down table in the kitchen.

But as it was never much good at holding a charge overnight I to  am puzzling over what to get as a replacement.

Been thinking  about the one Lidle have been advertising this week, but am now wondering if the  one from  Screwfix  would be better for general LIGHT DIY work.  Anyone got experience of either of them?

Ray

Bikeracer

Personally I'd steer clear of anything ni-cad or ni-mh powered and go for a lithium battery.

I've been very happy with the one in the link I posted earlier and can only endorse the reviews of it that have been posted on the Screwfix site.
It's also got a light for drilling or screwing in the dark,the light starts to flicker when it needs recharging.

Allan
I'm not a complete idiot..some bits are missing.

bbdave

We go through lots of drills at work the Erbauers we have had have given excellent service as have the Hitatchi Boshs etc.

The money is in the battery Nicd and Nimhs are good you just need to run them flat (NOT tape the trigger in)!!! and full charge them every few charges i don't know why people are anti they take alot more grief than lithium batteries,which are lighter so less weight to hold but the lithium batteries keep full power to discharge rather than the steady loss of Nicd/Nimh.

I would go for as high Ah as possible this gives it duration personally i don't use less than 18v but ours do get heavy use


Dave

Malc

You either buy a cheap/cheerful one and be prepared to throw it away afer 12 months, or invest in something half decent, like a Makita, or the one Bike racer posted from Screwfix. http://www.screwfix.com/p/erbauer-erp223ddh-10-8v-1-3ah-li-ion-cordless-drill-driver/52782. Erbauer have been around for ages and the thing I like is that they are quire light and ergan..ergun.. easy to hold.
The years have been good to me, it was the weekends that did the damage.

davieb

Hi Nick  :wave:

you could always try CPC they have replacement batteries for Bosch power tools

not the easiest site to navigate

http://cpc.farnell.com/

hope this is of some help

dave  :thumbsup:

Rob H

The old adage measure twice cut once is similar when buying a cordless drill - buy well, buy once !!
For me Dewalt knocks everything else into a cocked hat  -  ask TANK !!

Recently B & Q had them on offer with 2 batteries for £99

Rob.
They say that love is more important than money but have you ever tried to pay a bill with a hug ?

Calnefoxile


Erm guys, I'm a bit confused here  :confused2: :confused2:

I've just looked at the battery for my Bosch drill, which is also fubar'd, and it gives me a part number of 2607335273, it also states 12v - 1.2Ah and its Ni-CD. So i went onto the CPC website as Dave mentioned and guess what!! they don't have my model  :hmmm: :hmmm:

So I went to Fleabay and typed in the Part number in the search function and got the following http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/12V-3-0Ah-battery-for-Bosch-2607335273-BAT043-BAT045-GSB-12-VE-2-GSR-12-VE-2-UK-/160921676500?pt=UK_Home_Garden_PowerTools_SM&hash=item2577adead4 which is a 3.0Ah battery, now my question is ('cos I'm having a senior moment, and keep talking myself out of my answer  ;) ) will it make any difference with the original battery being 1.2Ah and a pattern part replacement being 3.0Ah???

I don't think it will, but my alter ego says "oh yes it will" and I keep arguing with myself  :worried: :worried:

Cheers

Neal.

saddler

should in theory work ok but your charger may take an age to charge it up  ;)

GlenP

I'd go with the above advice on buying decent! I got a cheap DirectPower cordless from Screwfix as a present and it's blooming useless! Good job it came with two batteries as even with care and conditioning they don't last long froma full charge.

The main problem with NiMh batteries is the self-discharge rate, if you don't use them they go flat quite quickly.

Most of the stuff on the railway has been done with a Ryobi cordless screwdriver. It's got a Lithium battery, only 4v but runs for ever and is small enough to get into tight spaces. It'll drill up to 5mm in timber without any problems at all. It is my second one, unfortuately the first one died after several years use (mechanical rather than electrical failure or I would probably have changed the battery). Having bought the first one cheap complete with case, accessories, etc. I was quite pleased to buy a replacement cheap in a blister-pack and keep the old bits!

Some time soon I'm going to be hunting for a Lithium cordless drill so I'll bear the above advice in mind!

Glen

upnick

Many thanks to you all  lots of good information to sift through  :thumbsup:

Please Support Us!
July Goal: £100.00
Due Date: Jul 31
Total Receipts: £43.45
Below Goal: £56.55
Site Currency: GBP
43% 
July Donations