Exhibition standards

Started by Newportnobby, November 16, 2026, 12:39:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Timbo66 and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Platy767

Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Today</strong> at 05:46:46 AMI mixed Metcalfe, Kestrel, Scenecraft and scratchbuilt on my first N gauge layout. It looked OK to my eyes and I never heard anyone moan.


I'm moaning. Bring back the Ridgacre Branch! I'll sign the petition!

I think it was a great example of a compact N gauge layout that looked really good, demonstrated would could be done and would be quite at home at both "shows" as well as "exhibitions/expos". Unfortunately I've only seen videos, posts and magazine articles of it and that will have to do.

Mark

ntpntpntp

Quote from: PLD on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:40:10 AM...if you stuck a Metcalfe house in the middle of that row it would look wrong...
... and the local community would be asking who brown-enveloped a load of cash to the planning regulator :) As we know it does happen in the real world that buildings get replaced with out-of-character monstrosities :)
Nick.   2026 celebrating the 30th anniversary of "Königshafen" exhibition layout!
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=50050.0

chrism

Quote from: PLD on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:40:10 AMIt's if you stuck a Metcalfe house in the middle of that row it would look wrong...

Not necessarily - it depends on how the town developed.

There are many streets in Millom where the house style varies, even within terraces. It's because the building was done in blocks with gaps between them, then the gaps were filled in, sometimes by a different builder.

One road in particular consists of a terrace of 17 houses in 5 structural styles - one pair, a row of 6, a single and 2 blocks of 4. Then, within the structural style blocks there are variations in the finish, stone, rendered and pebble-dashed, and variations in porch designs.


Chris Morris

Quote from: Platy767 on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:52:40 AM
Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Today</strong> at 05:46:46 AMI mixed Metcalfe, Kestrel, Scenecraft and scratchbuilt on my first N gauge layout. It looked OK to my eyes and I never heard anyone moan.


I'm moaning. Bring back the Ridgacre Branch! I'll sign the petition!

I think it was a great example of a compact N gauge layout that looked really good, demonstrated would could be done and would be quite at home at both "shows" as well as "exhibitions/expos". Unfortunately I've only seen videos, posts and magazine articles of it and that will have to do.

Mark
Thanks but there is no way back for it as it was binned some years ago. It was an interesting layout to run in a very small space - 44in by 27in and had 3 stations plus a couple of storage sidings in that space. The Ridgacre branch broke a couple of rules so in theory it could not be a good layout. As stated above it mixed various building types. Worse than that it used some setrack R1 curves and a Peco small radius point. It did work reliably and there was always plenty of activity at exhibitions. I always loved the working semaphores and the hands free shunting, both things I have used again since. That size layout was an excellent way to start out in N and learn a lot about the scale. I would recommend first timers go for something small that can completed before going on to anything more ambitious. For exhibitions it was great that it was just a single board that fitted in the back of the car. The size of the layout was dictated by the size of my car boot when I was building it but I changed my car before I took it to exhibitions so it could have been bigger. I have thought about building an improved version over the years but I have moved on. Here is the Ridgacre branch in its entirety.


Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Chris Morris

Quote from: chrism on <strong>Today</strong> at 10:58:19 AM
Quote from: PLD on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:40:10 AMIt's if you stuck a Metcalfe house in the middle of that row it would look wrong...

Not necessarily - it depends on how the town developed.

There are many streets in Millom where the house style varies, even within terraces. It's because the building was done in blocks with gaps between them, then the gaps were filled in, sometimes by a different builder.

One road in particular consists of a terrace of 17 houses in 5 structural styles - one pair, a row of 6, a single and 2 blocks of 4. Then, within the structural style blocks there are variations in the finish, stone, rendered and pebble-dashed, and variations in porch designs.
When it comes to semi-detached houses the Metcalfe ones looked to be a different scale to the Kestrel. I don't think they could ever have looked right in the same street. I always weathered my Metcalfe buildings as well as colouring in the corners. These two little things made them much more believable.
Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Chris Morris

I'm not sure about my most recent N gauge layout Cwm Bach. It was never meant for exhibitions but I modified it a little so it could be taken out on the road. I have done two exhibitions with it but the reaction to it has been somewhat underwhelming. I think it is good but it is very much a shelf layout in that it is only 7 inches deep and does in fact live on a shelf. That might well be what leaves visitors not so interested. The Ridgacre branch got a much better reaction at exhibitions even though in many ways Cwm Bach is a better quality layout. At the moment I don't really think it is worth taking to any more exhibitions but maybe it would work at something like TINGS as a "look what you can do in N in an unusual space" type layout. I dare say I could take it to some little local shows but, as it wasn't designed as an exhibition layout, it is a bit of a fiddle to set up. 

 So a question for readers here - is this layout worth exhibiting or is it best kept on my shelf at home? Don't worry, I can take honest views.
Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Newportnobby

#66
Simply put "Exhibit it"!
It does show off the advantage of N gauge (i.e. small space) and could bring potential returners to model railways back into the fold, and makes it easier for youngsters to persuade parents they could find space at home :)

ntpntpntp

Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Today</strong> at 11:06:44 AMWhen it comes to semi-detached houses the Metcalfe ones looked to be a different scale to the Kestrel.
I'm not a fan of card buildings anyway, but I agree Metcalfe often look over-scale to me (made even worse as I'm more used to 1:160 than 1:148 so Metcalfe doorways look huge!)
Nick.   2026 celebrating the 30th anniversary of "Königshafen" exhibition layout!
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=50050.0

Roy L S

I have always really liked Cwm Bach, I think it is well put together, nicely detailed and very innovative in achieving as much as it does in the space available. It is definitely worth exhibiting, and for a variety of reasons can see it being a really attractive prospect for an exhibition manager.


Newportnobby

Quote from: chrism on <strong>Today</strong> at 10:58:19 AM
Quote from: PLD on <strong>Today</strong> at 09:40:10 AMIt's if you stuck a Metcalfe house in the middle of that row it would look wrong...

Not necessarily - it depends on how the town developed.

There are many streets in Millom where the house style varies, even within terraces. It's because the building was done in blocks with gaps between them, then the gaps were filled in, sometimes by a different builder.

One road in particular consists of a terrace of 17 houses in 5 structural styles - one pair, a row of 6, a single and 2 blocks of 4. Then, within the structural style blocks there are variations in the finish, stone, rendered and pebble-dashed, and variations in porch designs.

I put the blame fairly and squarely on Kevin McCloud (Grand Designs) ;D

Southerngooner

I think CwmBach gives a positive view of what can be done with N in reduced space. Long and thin layouts in larger scales leave me cold but in N, 7" is OK with the length you have. Much better than a routine 4' x 2' loco depot or goods yard in OO


Dave


Dave

Builder of "Brickmakers Lane" and member of "James Street" operating team.

Steven B

From the photos I've seen, Cwm Bach is a lovely layout. Have you approached any of the magazines to see if they'd be interested in featuring it?

Making it visible to a wider audience may increase invites - perhaps start a thread on RMWeb too?

The only bit of the layout I'm not too keen on is the loop for the halt. I can see how it adds operational interest, but I think a basic single sided platform would be more in keeping with the scene.

I wonder if it's just that long, thin layouts don't attract viewers. There was a very long, thin, layout on the exhibition circuit a while ago - called "The Long Line" or similar. I remember seeing it at the NEC - good modelling but nobody looking at it. Perhaps there's an ideal length:depth ratio and long:thin just doesn't appeal?

Chris Morris

Quote from: Steven B on <strong>Today</strong> at 01:40:59 PMFrom the photos I've seen, Cwm Bach is a lovely layout. Have you approached any of the magazines to see if they'd be interested in featuring it?

Making it visible to a wider audience may increase invites - perhaps start a thread on RMWeb too?
I'm not really short of invites. I have a number of exhibition manager contacts who might be interested if I offered it to them. I just haven't felt like offering it out. This is not a sad thing because I have spent the last 12 months building an 009 layout . It was in RM as a plan of the month last year.

Quote from: Steven B on <strong>Today</strong> at 01:40:59 PMThe only bit of the layout I'm not too keen on is the loop for the halt. I can see how it adds operational interest, but I think a basic single sided platform would be more in keeping with the scene.
I can't disagree with you on that. The loop was put in purely to provide operational interest.   The island platform with a bridge to it was inspired by Rotton Park Road station on the Harborne line. See https://www.warwickshirerailways.com/lms/lnwrrp85.htm .


Quote from: Steven B on <strong>Today</strong> at 01:40:59 PMI wonder if it's just that long, thin layouts don't attract viewers. There was a very long, thin, layout on the exhibition circuit a while ago - called "The Long Line" or similar. I remember seeing it at the NEC - good modelling but nobody looking at it. Perhaps there's an ideal length:depth ratio and long:thin just doesn't appeal?
I think you may well have a good point there. While it works for me on a shelf at home it probably doesn't look very interesting at an exhibition amongst all the other layouts. It takes up quite a length at just over 12 foot so it does look a bit "spindley" at an exhibition. On reflection its not a great layout for exhibitions even though I really enjoy running it at home. The layout runs fine and I think the scenery is OK but maybe the charm of an N gauge railcar working its way gently along around 10ft of branch line with only a narrow scenic section just doesn't really work for most exhibition visitors. Maybe that's another thought for exhibition standards; all layouts need to have a certain stage presence in order to appeal to visitors. My new 009 layout has a number of gimmicks interesting features which I think give it a bit more presence than Cwm Bach.
Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Timbo66

I prefer local shows to the big nationals, mostly because the latter usually mean a long drive from the South Coast. I spend time looking at layouts I like and tend to bypass those I don`t, One of my favourites locally is a pretty basic model of a local station. The buildings are painted on to white card, don`t fit particularly well to the baseboard, the perspective is, er, interesting and so on. The builder is a delightful chap, brimming over with enthusiasm for his layout and it runs all the time.
 I do expect to see a generally higher standard at the big show though. We did go to a larger local earlier this year where about 30% of the layouts weren`t actually working! I left quite disappointed.

Please Support Us!
November Goal: £100.00
Due Date: Nov 30
Total Receipts: £45.00
Below Goal: £55.00
Site Currency: GBP
45% 
November Donations