Exhibition standards

Started by Newportnobby, November 16, 2026, 12:39:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Greygreaser, Train Waiting, Ensign Elliott and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

PLD

Quote from: PLD on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 09:27:51 AMA place for a well thought out, well presented, well operated "starter" layout using readily available off the shelf materials showing what is achievable by the beginner - absolutely...  :thumbsup:
Deliberately making something run poorly or deliberately operating badly - definitely NO...  :thumbsdown:
Interested that the above post has attracted a few "Disagree" reactions.

For future planning, I'm genuinely interested to understand which part you disagree with...

Do you believe that exhibitions should NOT include "starter" layouts achievable by the average modeller ??
or
Do you think that exhibitions SHOULD include something deliberately built poorly and operated badly.

???  ???
Hull Model Railway Show: 5 & 6  June 2027
https://hullmodelrailwayshow.blogspot.com

njee20

And if you do want something deliberately badly built and run terribly then I am your man!

GlenEglise

Quote from: PLD on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 01:14:13 PMmaybe could have worded a bit clearer...
If you have a street of 4 brick-built houses, if they're all plastic kits or all card kits, they present a consistent and coherent whole.
If you have 3 of one and an odd one of the other it stands out like a sore thumb...

Show me a street in any major town where something doesn't match the neetness you seem to require. I am sure there are plenty of examples.

GE

rog

Quote from: njee20 on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 08:50:22 PMAnd if you do want something deliberately badly built and run terribly then I am your man!
Me too!

EtchedPixels

Quote from: Greygreaser on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 02:14:42 PMRe: club layouts - I visited a club which was very 'active' according to their website and news items, promoting MR yearly with an exhibition. Didn't join because it seemed to be over-organised with committee and sub-groups who potentially spent more time compromising than modelling. In one night of 3 hours there was diddly squat done on the layouts, much discussion and lots tea drunk.

I can think of plenty of clubs where much is said, much tea is drunk and work rarely gets done. Sometimes that's want the membership wants, a chance for a good natter over tea out of reach of their partner and possibly pies or beer after  :D

I don't see the problem, unless obviously you wanted to join a club that did stuff, in which case wrong club.
"Knowledge has no value or use for the solitary owner: to be enjoyed it must be communicated" -- Charles Pratt, 1st Earl Camden

EtchedPixels

Quote from: Greygreaser on November 16, 2026, 03:41:40 PMAt the point of exhibiting, which I've not attempted yet, we should be seeing a complete scenario in which the railway functions as would the prototype. That's modelling a railway which we surely aim for, otherwise it's a trainset!

Trainsets have their place at exhibitions. They can be fun to operate, let the kids have a thing they built and exhibited themselves and lots more.

I have been pondering a super accurate model that functions as the prototype. It would be called "South West Wales Sunday" and consist of a fixed diorama with a looping sound announcing that the replacement bus will be found out the back (not visible) of the station.
"Knowledge has no value or use for the solitary owner: to be enjoyed it must be communicated" -- Charles Pratt, 1st Earl Camden

ntpntpntp

Quote from: Greygreaser on November 16, 2026, 03:41:40 PMAt the point of exhibiting, which I've not attempted yet, we should be seeing a complete scenario in which the railway functions as would the prototype. That's modelling a railway which we surely aim for, otherwise it's a trainset!

Unfortunately this can lead to the "branch-line running to a Tuesday afternoon timetable in 1952" layout which might be beautifully modelled and correct train formations and movements but I'm afraid is a complete turn-off for me.   I want to see trains running - as do the majority of the general public in my experience - so that's what I try and achieve with my layouts. They may end up a bit "train-set" but stuff is always running :)
Nick.   2026 celebrating the 30th anniversary of "Königshafen" exhibition layout!
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=50050.0


Chris Morris

I mixed Metcalfe, Kestrel, Scenecraft and scratchbuilt on my first N gauge layout. It looked OK to my eyes and I never heard anyone moan.


Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Chris Morris

#54
Quote from: Newportnobby on <strong>Today</strong> at 02:26:23 AM

Done that, albeit not at an exhibition.



Shortly after this photo was taken the whole thing was in the bin.
Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Chris Morris

I missed most of yesterday's comments because I was at the model railway club. I can't see anyone deliberately building a bad layout but its fair to say there are different levels of ability and different people are trying to achieve different things. Personally my N gauge layouts have to be run with reasonably accurate trains whether at home or at exhibition. I fully accept however that many folk just like to run trains. There are quite a few modellers who have no interest in real trains and there are some that just like to run pretty trains. We are all different and while I prefer to see "proper" layouts running "proper" trains I think there is room for layouts that are more fanciful even at exhibitions. I quite enjoy watching some of them. We all have our own boundaries as to what is and isn't acceptable. Personally I get a bit disappointed when someone has built an exhibition layout and can't be bothered to paint the sides of the rails - that's just lazy.

I break my above rule on running reasonably accurate trains when very little ones are present and Thomas comes out for a run. There are limits to this though, I could never let Thomas out on Dawlish Warren at an exhibition because, for me, that would be too wrong.  Thomas does occasionally come out on my other layouts which have a fictional location. Sometimes at the behest of adults.
Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Bazza

Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Today</strong> at 05:46:46 AMI mixed Metcalfe, Kestrel, Scenecraft and scratchbuilt on my first N gauge layout. It looked OK to my eyes and I never heard anyone moan.


I agree. It's quite possible to include buildings made from various modelling materials, RTP, kits or scratch built, and from various manufacturers on a layout without them looking incongruous. It's more about appropriate selection, the location they're installed, how they're blended in to the overall scene, their finish and weathering, and ensuring they don't betray their original heritage.

Foxhound

Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Today</strong> at 05:46:46 AMI mixed Metcalfe, Kestrel, Scenecraft and scratchbuilt on my first N gauge layout. It looked OK to my eyes and I never heard anyone moan.



Chris that's beautiful. I aspire to that level of detail. Great work.
Rob and Becky (artistic director)

Foxhound

#58
Quote from: PLD on <strong>Yesterday</strong> at 08:43:54 PMDo you believe that exhibitions should NOT include "starter" layouts achievable by the average modeller ??
or
Do you think that exhibitions SHOULD include something deliberately built poorly and operated badly.

???  ???
I was not a 'disagreer', however....

I think Starter layouts are essential at exhibitions.

I've seen four planks joined together to form a double loop and some sidings, with a rudimentary pair of platforms and some basic signalling at an exhibition last year, whose sole aim was to promote another scale (Tiny Tonka) and DCC sound.

Whilst not my scale, it did show how a layout begins its life.

When the same layout returns to next year's show I have no doubt it will be a much developed beast, albeit still just running 37s, 50s and HSTs.

Deliberately poorly built and badly operated? Perhaps not, unless they name it 'Whatnottodo Junction' or somesuch.
Rob and Becky (artistic director)

Please Support Us!
November Goal: £100.00
Due Date: Nov 30
Total Receipts: £45.00
Below Goal: £55.00
Site Currency: GBP
45% 
November Donations