Exhibition standards

Started by Newportnobby, Today at 12:39:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Newportnobby, Chris Morris, GrahamB, Foxhound and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Newportnobby

Having watched some YouTube videos covering some exhibitions this year I am struck by many issues with layouts such as:-

Poor running (yes, we all have gremlins now and then, and they do seem to occur at unfortunate times e.g. when being filmed)

Poor track – some obviously uncleaned and some iffy track joins

Buildings e.g. stations 'floating' as they've just been plonked down with no attempt to bed them into the scenery

Tatty and/or peeling backscenes

Same trains going round and round while the operator(s) natter to mates

Unlikely scenarios e.g. an Ivatt 2MT tank loco with a 2 coach B set obviously on a shuttle unit but openly exiting through a hole in a warehouse and stuttering to a halt in a station before returning through the hole.

Just an undisguised hole in a backscene for trains to exit the scenic part (one of my pet hates)

The thing is, the clubs owning these layouts deem them suitable for exhibiting and seem happy to put them on display. Our club compiles a list of things to be done before any of our layouts get out of the clubroom door and ensures they are all completed before a show.
I appreciate things get may damaged in transit but surely some attempt at repair is made during set up. Running can be affected by conditions in the hall, especially with temperature changes but, again, these should be sorted where possible before opening times.
 
I haven't even mentioned the hoary old 'Why is nothing running here?' gripe often heard.
I've no issue with a 'Work in progress' being exhibited providing it's clearly marked as such

Am I being over critical? I'd like to think not, and would maybe seek (constructive) criticism/praise before volunteering a layout for a show.

What says the 'Collective', please?

Chris Morris

I hope you have your tin hat on!

I tend to agree with much of what you say. I went to a little local exhibition a few weeks ago and it was exactly what I expected - nearly all the layouts were very poor. It's what you expect for £7 admission. Shows like Stafford, Abingdon and the NEC are much more expensive but actually much better value because the quality of the layouts is much higher.

In many ways I am reluctant to criticise poor quality layouts at exhibitions because someone has invested time, thought and effort into building a (mostly) working layout that can be transported. So, no matter how poor I think a layout might be, I respect that the builder has achieved something. I would love to say to exhibitors "have you thought of ..." and suggesting improvements but my thoughts probably would not be well received. As an exhibitor I find some viewers comments useful in terms of improving my layouts.

Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

ntpntpntp

This old topic again! :)

Yes some things grate on me: poor running, stalling, frequent uncoupling, unrealistic stop/starts, battered backscenes, broken buildings and details, untidy front presentation etc.  Accidents and gremlins happen but generally it's clearly stuff that should be sorted before bringing the layout to the show. 
Nick.   2026 celebrating the 30th anniversary of "Königshafen" exhibition layout!
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=50050.0

Ensign Elliott

#3
This has been a bit of gripe of mine for some years now but something I've normally kept to myself - however, I'll put on my tin hat!  :D 

I tend to avoid the very small, village hall type shows, as my experience with them has generally been poor. I personally think that exhibitions where I am asked to pay a higher entry fee, plus petrol etc, should be showcasing the very best that our hobby has to offer.

I think the issue is more prevalent in N Gauge where there are far less layouts on the exhibition circuit which, for me, hit the "exhibition standard" label.

My issues with a lot of N gauge layouts at shows are:

Trains racing round at unrealistic, racetrack speeds
Poor, overscale ballasting
Lumpy, poorly laid track, or worse, layouts comprised of settrack.
Unrealistic train formations and mix of eras (ie. EWS 37 hauling 1930s wagons)
Overly bright, radioactive green scenery
Broken scenic items like streetlights etc
Unrealistic, poor quality buildings
Layouts dominated by gimmicky, plasticky scenarios such as moving fairgrounds, RTCs with flashing lights etc..

There is little excuse for any of the above given the fact that we probably now have the biggest and most diverse range of quality model suppliers in the hobbies' history.

I've been to 4 of the larger shows over the past couple of months and left 3 of them feeling distinctly unimpressed by the quality of layouts at them, in all gauges but especially in N.
That's not to say there weren't great layouts there, its just that I felt they were in the minority.

I was also disappointed at the quality of traders at some shows recently. Very few of the smaller traders selling specific scenic or electronic items, and lots of traders purely selling brand new 00 gauge diesels. At the last large show I went to, one area had 4 traders just selling the same locos, at the same prices. There was only one trader at the entire show who was selling a decent range of scenic or electronic items. I went to purchase a standard Peco point motor and not one trader had them, or anything similar, on sale. Tons of Bachmann class 69s though...

The exception was the Stafford show which I thought had a good range of different traders and good layouts.

The "why is nothing running here" gripe never really bothers me too much. If the layout is exhibition quality, with superb scenery and lots of detail, then I can spend 10 mins or so taking it all in, without really needing to see a running train. 

I appreciate that I'm probably a bit of a rivet counter, and that the hobby is a broad church.  I also appreciate that show organisers can only have layouts that are offered to them, and often have little control over quality issues. There are some absolutely outstanding N Gauge layouts on the exhibition circuit and I realise they can't all attend every show, every year. 







Steven B

Is an undisguised hole in the back scene a lesser evil than an incongruous bridge or tunnel?

Talking of tunnels - how about the large building plonked on top of a shallow tunnel? Possibly worse if a church where the grave occupants would be floating mid-tunnel.

I also find road layouts are often an after thought - either too steep or with bends to tight that the wagons in the goods yard wouldn't have a chance of being able to get out in on peice.

Chris Morris

#5
Quote from: Ensign Elliott on <strong>Today</strong> at 02:05:57 PMLayouts dominated by gimmicky, plasticky scenarios such as moving fairgrounds, RTCs with flashing lights etc..
Oh Rob, I guess you didn't like my new layout with a paleontological dig, an animated playground, a Rattler cyder barrel wagon and worst of all it's not even N gauge.   ;)

https://youtu.be/C6uqDm-ZzMs?si=RBSu2k30ux2XLpL6
At least I avoided any welding scene and, being a larger scale, I have flocked my sheep.

Quote from: Ensign Elliott on <strong>Today</strong> at 02:05:57 PMI was also disappointed at the quality of traders at some shows recently. Very few of the smaller traders selling specific scenic or electronic items, and lots of traders purely selling brand new 00 gauge diesels.
I think this is a big problem for shows. During Covid traders learnt to live off online sales and since Covid costs of going to exhibitions have gone up.
Working doesn't seem to be the perfect thing for me so I'll continue to play.
Steve Marriott / Ronnie Lane

Ensign Elliott

Quote from: Chris Morris on <strong>Today</strong> at 02:49:25 PMOh Rob, I guess you didn't like my new layout with a paleontological dig, an animated playground, a Rattler cyder barrel wagon and worst of all it's not even N gauge.  ;)

Haha, I knew you'd say that - your layouts are excellent Chris 

Foxhound

Quote from: Ensign Elliott on <strong>Today</strong> at 02:05:57 PMMy issues with a lot of N gauge layouts at shows are:

Trains racing round at unrealistic, racetrack speeds
Poor, overscale ballasting
Lumpy, poorly laid track, or worse, layouts comprised of settrack.
Unrealistic train formations and mix of eras (ie. EWS 37 hauling 1930s wagons)
Overly bright, radioactive green scenery
Broken scenic items like streetlights etc
Unrealistic, poor quality buildings
Layouts dominated by gimmicky, plasticky scenarios such as moving fairgrounds, RTCs with flashing lights etc..

There is little excuse for any of the above given the fact that we probably now have the biggest and most diverse range of quality model suppliers in the hobbies' history.


Unrealistic speeds are irritating, alth0ough I sometimes do it at home to send videos to German chums who then have a fit about it. All in fun.
Ballasting is a nightmare, and I have respect for anyone who gets it looking right. Your layout Lostwithiel does look good.

I think there is a place for Settrack and Kato Unitrack in exhibitions, as it shows people what can be achieved for less outlay and might encourage more people to the hobby. I am not (and never will be) an exhibitor, and I love Unitrack, it's made my life much easier.

Unrealistic formations can be an irritant but a bit of Rule One is fine, particularly if kits or RTR of what was prototypical aren't available (Class 118 power twins on the Gunnislake branch, for example, which you can't buy).

Lime green grass is very off-putting - always helps to add scatter or dry brush some earthy tones.

Poor quality buildings are a problem, but even good quality ones can be damaged in transit. Anyone using Metcalfe will know the horror of the lost chimney pot.

Moving scenarios like fairgrounds will attract youngsters a bit. Not my thing necessarily, however, I would happily have a moving windmill or wind turbine if I had space.
Rob and Becky (artistic director)

Greygreaser

Hamley's toy shop layouts with fast running "odd" trains!

Can tolerate a lot of minor things like the 'hole in the wall' exit from the main modelled area as long as the modelling is quality stuff. Several decent attempts let down by the Backscene, most notably industrial or town scenes with a white board backing. Poor finishing of track and ballast rankle too!

At the point of exhibiting, which I've not attempted yet, we should be seeing a complete scenario in which the railway functions as would the prototype. That's modelling a railway which we surely aim for, otherwise it's a trainset!
A jack of all trades is a master of none, but often times better than a master of one.

PLD

OK with Exhibition Manager hat on... What do we look for when selecting layouts for our shows...

Criteria number 1 is "Does it work well" (i.e. minimal number [won't say none at all 'cause thats near impossible] of sticks/stops/stutters/hands-of-god) - Fail on that one, and it doesn't matter about anything else you're not getting in...

Second is Presentation - How does it look (no tatty edges or battered paintwork); is it well lit (please no 1000w spotlights pointed at the audience); Curtains to hide the legs and junk underneath (preferably plain dark or neutral colour, long enough to hide the junk but not so long to be a trip hazard or fire hazard). I do like a Pelmet or header board to help frame the scene but not necessarily essential.

Third Realistic Operation - realistic speed (including acceleration/deceleration) simply needs operators with a bit of discipline in use of the throttle! Remembering to set the correct route so no sudden stops and reversals, crashes, derailments. Sensible train formations, Might let the "Ivatt on a B-Set slide", but Class 66's definitely did not work with Auto-coaches...

Fourthly plausibility of the landscape - the too shallow to support itself tunnel roof is an obvious one, and also dislike the 'random tunnel or bridge to hide the exit' One of the worst examples had a road and a railway disappear into the same random green-painted lump at angles that could only have led to an underground level crossing!

Finally the overall standard of the modelling. Here we're actually looking for consistency such that everything fits and gels together. for example Buildings of the same material (Metcalfe card kits are ok, but then use only card kits and don't mix with plastic kits). Generally the "Consistently Average" works better here than the "Outstanding in Parts/mediocre in others"...
Hull Model Railway Show: 5 & 6  June 2027
https://hullmodelrailwayshow.blogspot.com

lil chris

Well now that my layout is on the exhibition side of the world, in my case just opendays for the club not actual exhibitions. I had so much trouble last Saturday nothing would run yet I had a run session on the previous Wednesday with no hiccups. Saturday the gremlins came out, certain locos would not run, track joins all of a sudden started causing derailments when they had not previuosly. Fortunately when a Paying member of the public started to film my layout everything was running but I was guilty of running the two same locos round because I could rely on those to keep running, it was nightmare for me. I wanted to vary my stock running round and use my fiddle yard to it's potential. Also My Android pad ( the controller using mt z21 )had been left at the club still plugged into a charger, the battery had gone flat. Luckily I had taken a second one with me which was freshly charged. I put the bad running at the start with the room being cold and there being moisture in the air, Another N gauge user, his layout was anolouge had similar problems.
Chris H.
Lil Chris
My new layout  East Lancashire Railway
My old layout was Irwell Valley Railway.
Layout previous was East Lancashire Lines, changed this new one. My new layout here.
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=57193.0

Please Support Us!
November Goal: £100.00
Due Date: Nov 30
Total Receipts: £45.00
Below Goal: £55.00
Site Currency: GBP
45% 
November Donations