Building opinion needed

[grumbeast]

Hi All,

 I'm having second thoughts about putting the hospital (pic 1) on the hill on Wittanheim so I thought I'd ask opinions.  It seems to overwhelm the area.  SO I'm thinking of a swanky guesthouse instead (pic 2) with a nice driveway, maybe with some poplars lining it.

Here are both ideas, any opinions would be welcome and please forgive the terrible embellishments!

Hospital



Swanky Guesthouse



Thanks! 

G

[port perran]

I agree, that hospital does rather dominate.

The guest house is better but is it to scale?
It does look a bit over sized or is that just the camera exaggerating it?

[grumbeast]

T

I agree, that hospital does rather dominate.

The guest house is better but is it to scale?
It does look a bit over sized or is that just the camera exaggerating it?

I think its the camera, its not overscale but it is quite a big building, I probably should have said small hotel

G.

[port perran]

T

I agree, that hospital does rather dominate.

The guest house is better but is it to scale?
It does look a bit over sized or is that just the camera exaggerating it?

I think its the camera, its not overscale but it is quite a big building, I probably should have said small hotel

G.

Ok, in that case yes the guest house/ hotel does sit better rather than the hospital.

[emjaybee]

Hi All,

 I'm having second thoughts about putting the hospital (pic 1) on the hill on Wittanheim so I thought I'd ask opinions.  It seems to overwhelm the area.  SO I'm thinking of a swanky guesthouse instead (pic 2) with a nice driveway, maybe with some poplars lining it.

Here are both ideas, any opinions would be welcome and please forgive the terrible embellishments!

Hospital



Swanky Guesthouse



Thanks! 

G

Why is the hospital eight storeys?

I work at a private hospital in Oxford & it's four storeys.

Why not reduce the hospital in height, it would reduce the impact somewhat.

[crewearpley40]

Agree with Martin and Michael

Looked like a hotel or tower block but 4 storeys would look better!


Which manufacturer made the building please?


Can you split it / kitbash it into two four storey?