Thomas or chuggington

[lionwing]

Tough one!

Both are very well made programs but my own preference would be for Thomas...the pre-CGI version because while it retains a lot of the character and charm of the original it just "don't look right" !

Chuggington is OK but is just like so many kids recent kids programs...no originality and treats the kids like fools!

I will ask the same question of a five year expert on the topic later today!

[michael]

Prefer thomas pre cgi.


As for chungington and cgi Thomas ' it isnt wrong but we just dont do it!'

[Ozymandias]

Pre-CGI Thomas has to win, I think. But I have a bone to pick with Ringo Starr, because now whenever I read the books to my boys James's voice always comes out sounding like Steven Gerrard....

[Bealman]

 

[Ozymandias]

...and Emily sounds like Dame Maggie Smith as Miss Jean Brodie...

[chub1]

Thomas by a mile and
errrrrrrrrrrrr
Ringo

[dr deltic]

Thomas, despite the clearly hideous safety record on Sodor railways.

Chuggington spend half their time air borne (i have a 5 year old daughter so have to watch) and multi-storey depots.

It is a total bag of , CGI at that.

Bit biased me 

[glenng]

It's got to be Ivor the engine.   :D

[kirky]

Huh, I've just realised the mod police have moved this thread. When did that happen?

Kirky

[Agrippa]

Neither ,James  Bond  or Duckula.

[Ozymandias]

Ah, glenng, Ivor the Engine... you've taken me back 35 years!

"Hello Mr Jones, are you selling chestnuts?"

"No, I'm selling dragons!"

"Ooooh, I bet they're expensive...!"

Sigh...