N Gauge Forum

General Category => N Gauge Discussion => Topic started by: Le Night ferry on September 09, 2023, 03:12:25 PM

Title: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 09, 2023, 03:12:25 PM
British has lots of 4-6-0s, and also there's lots of model trains.
GWR
Saints-3d shell available.
Castles-Old Grafar and Bachfar make it
Kings-Old Grafar made it, but is repainted version of Castles?
Saints-3d shell available
Halls-Grafar and Dapol made it
Modified Halls-Nothng. Should w renumber original Halls?
Granges, Manors-Dapol made it
Counties-PD Marsh kits

LMS
Prince of Wales-Union Mills
Royal Scots-Bachfar. Maube old white metal kits.
Patriot-Bhe kits and 3d shell
Jubilee-Peco/Rivarossi and Grafar
Black 5-Grafar and Bachfar

LNER
B12-Union Mills
B17,B1-Dapol

SR
N15 King Arthur-Bhe kits
S15-Langley kits
H15-Seems like we need kitbashing

BR
4MT 4-6-0-Langley kits
5MT-Grafar/Bachfar


5AT Advanced Technology-Did someone ever tried this?

I heard KR models tried to make GWR Kings, but no news.
There will be more 4-6-0s prior 1922.
Well, why 4-4-2 Atlantic are scarce?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Newportnobby on September 09, 2023, 03:18:06 PM
Re Jubilee and 5MT - not sure these were ever made by GraFar but both were certainly BachFar.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: martyn on September 09, 2023, 03:41:28 PM
Farish also make a B1, it seems a more popular model than the Dapol one.

Union Mills have now ceased trading with no more models being made.

Models of Atlantics 4-4-2s may be scare as some of the real locos had very tight clearance between their driving wheels, (eg GNR and LBSCR Atlantics) and most were withdrawn by early BR days, so limited market.

Martyn
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: msr on September 09, 2023, 03:56:03 PM
Atlantics were discussed here last year:

Re: Next Union Mills Model will be...
#457
November 04, 2022, 05:59:25 PM
Actually there have been Atlantics produced in N, as discussed in the following thread a few years ago:
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=35986.msg425979#msg425979
Since then I've managed to acquire a Churchward 2900 (Saint) Class Scott Series in its early guise that has been converted from a Poole Farish Hall with a white metal Langley tender. It needed a bit of fettling but I couldn't find any early Saint plates and so it is numbered and named as 2932 'Ashton Court' using Fox Transfer etched plates which creates a nice model:

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/127/thumb_231-041122175349.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view;id=127315)
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 09, 2023, 11:38:51 PM
Quote from: msr on September 09, 2023, 03:56:03 PMAtlantics were discussed here last year:

Re: Next Union Mills Model will be...
#457
November 04, 2022, 05:59:25 PM
Actually there have been Atlantics produced in N, as discussed in the following thread a few years ago:
https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=35986.msg425979#msg425979
Since then I've managed to acquire a Churchward 2900 (Saint) Class Scott Series in its early guise that has been converted from a Poole Farish Hall with a white metal Langley tender. It needed a bit of fettling but I couldn't find any early Saint plates and so it is numbered and named as 2932 'Ashton Court' using Fox Transfer etched plates which creates a nice model:

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/127/thumb_231-041122175349.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view;id=127315)

Old Poole chassis? Is it hard to modify?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Dorsetmike on September 10, 2023, 12:24:29 AM
QuoteSR
N15 King Arthur-Bhe kits
S15-Langley kits
H15-Seems like we need kitbashing

The BHE and Langley kits are both for Urie versions, Maunsell versions need a bit of hacking, cab roofs for both kits, level over the cylinders, the Langley watercart tender oly relevant for a few S15s between mid 1930s and 50s, the BHE N15 tender can be used behind the Langley loco - you can then use the Langley watercart for some of the Drummond 4-4-0s eg T9. Urie H15 Langley loco BHE tender and a chassis with 6' drivers

What about the Nelsons?  Possible to hack a Jubilee or Scot
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 10, 2023, 08:36:45 AM
Quote from: Dorsetmike on September 10, 2023, 12:24:29 AM
QuoteSR
N15 King Arthur-Bhe kits
S15-Langley kits
H15-Seems like we need kitbashing

The BHE and Langley kits are both for Urie versions, Maunsell versions need a bit of hacking, cab roofs for both kits, level over the cylinders, the Langley watercart tender oly relevant for a few S15s between mid 1930s and 50s, the BHE N15 tender can be used behind the Langley loco - you can then use the Langley watercart for some of the Drummond 4-4-0s eg T9. Urie H15 Langley loco BHE tender and a chassis with 6' drivers

What about the Nelsons?  Possible to hack a Jubilee or Scot
Lord Nelson Class had 3d shell.
I forgot it
https://www.shapeways.com/product/Q846R366F/lord-nelson-body-n-gauge
Hope to more SR stuff, like LBSCR H2 Atlantic, E2 tank engine and finescale WC/BoB(Please, Dapol!)
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 10, 2023, 08:40:00 AM
Quote from: Newportnobby on September 09, 2023, 03:18:06 PMRe Jubilee and 5MT - not sure these were ever made by GraFar but both were certainly BachFar.

Quote from: martyn on September 09, 2023, 03:41:28 PMFarish also make a B1, it seems a more popular model than the Dapol one.

Union Mills have now ceased trading with no more models being made.

Models of Atlantics 4-4-2s may be scare as some of the real locos had very tight clearance between their driving wheels, (eg GNR and LBSCR Atlantics) and most were withdrawn by early BR days, so limited market.

Martyn
Yeah
I made some mistake
What if Beechy Head is complete?
Is it possible to see it in n gauge?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bealman on September 10, 2023, 08:43:03 AM
I've got a Dapol B1. It runs well, but there are some detail compromises compared to the Farish model.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 10, 2023, 08:51:37 AM
I have few information about Farish's Kings(Repainted Poole Castle?) and seems like KR Model's Kings are cancelled.
How's about Modified Hall?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 10, 2023, 09:08:01 AM
Quote from: Bealman on September 10, 2023, 08:43:03 AMI've got a Dapol B1. It runs well, but there are some detail compromises compared to the Farish model.
Farish detail is better, but for riding performance , Dapol is better than Bachfar?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bealman on September 10, 2023, 09:14:13 AM
I only have the Dapol model, so can't compare it to the Farish one. My Dapol model runs very smoothly, even at very low speed. Actually it's a pleasure to watch the motion at a crawl.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: leachsprite4 on September 10, 2023, 09:24:08 AM
Not sure what happened as I thought I replied.

The Farish Hall is the modified hall, but runs made with original hall name and numbers and with the less commonly used tender for a modified hall.

The Farish king is not a repainted Farish castle. At the very least it has a different running plate and smoke box.

But yes both are very old models.

The gap in n gauge really is southern ready to 4-6-0 locos

Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 10, 2023, 10:32:22 AM
Quote from: leachsprite4 on September 10, 2023, 09:24:08 AMNot sure what happened as I thought I replied.

The Farish Hall is the modified hall, but runs made with original hall name and numbers and with the less commonly used tender for a modified hall.

The Farish king is not a repainted Farish castle. At the very least it has a different running plate and smoke box.

But yes both are very old models.

The gap in n gauge really is southern ready to 4-6-0 locos


Gonna purchase th later.
And replace bogies and attach handrails.
Hope to make King George V, first revival Steam Locomotove
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 10, 2023, 11:36:59 AM
Well' Is it okay to custimize Dapol's Hall to Modified Hall?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: leachsprite4 on September 10, 2023, 01:25:08 PM
The best thing to do is get scale drawings of both on line. There are subtle differences in the engine which could be acceptable, the challenge will be if you want the welded Hawksworth tender as the whole tender would need replacing and that is more complicated with the motor being housed in it.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: PLD on September 10, 2023, 06:53:51 PM
Quote from: Le Night ferry on September 10, 2023, 09:08:01 AM
Quote from: Bealman on September 10, 2023, 08:43:03 AMI've got a Dapol B1. It runs well, but there are some detail compromises compared to the Farish model.
Farish detail is better, but for riding performance , Dapol is better than Bachfar?
the majority opinion is that the Farish version wins on appearance for finesse of the small details.
Mechanically the farish is tender driven and some have found the loco lrone to locking up and skidding along pushed by the tender. The Dapol version is driven by the loco wheels from a motor mounted in the tender and a drive shaft. The farish version relies on spring contacts to carry power from the loco pickups to the tender, dapol is hard-wired which is in theory more reliable but the wires are prone to breaking with rough handling. Result is a near 50:50 split in opinion of which is the better overall...
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 12, 2023, 04:05:58 AM
Recently found company named Foxhunter made white metal kits for GWR Kings.
Do you have information about it?
Foxhunter site is gone...
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: icairns on September 12, 2023, 05:01:27 AM


Foxhunter kits are long out of production but they did make a kit for a King 4-6-0 as shown below.  The only way to obtain one now would be on the second-hand market. 

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045526.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135547)

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045610.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135548)

Here is a link to an old thread with some information about Foxhunter from circa 2009:

https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=45761.msg581661#msg581661

Ian


Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 12, 2023, 05:18:25 AM
Quote from: icairns on September 12, 2023, 05:01:27 AMFoxhunter kits are long out of production but they did make a kit for a King 4-6-0 as shown below.  The only way to obtain one now would be on the second-hand market. 

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045526.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135547)

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045610.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135548)

Here is a link to an old thread with some information about Foxhunter from circa 2009:

https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=45761.msg581661#msg581661

Ian



GF Castle will be old Poole version of it, right?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: martyn on September 12, 2023, 08:10:32 AM
Quote from: Le Night ferry on September 12, 2023, 05:18:25 AM
Quote from: icairns on September 12, 2023, 05:01:27 AMFoxhunter kits are long out of production but they did make a kit for a King 4-6-0 as shown below.  The only way to obtain one now would be on the second-hand market. 

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045526.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135547)

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045610.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135548)

Here is a link to an old thread with some information about Foxhunter from circa 2009:

https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=45761.msg581661#msg581661

Ian



GF Castle will be old Poole version of it, right?

Yes, the Poole version, as were all the chassis used for different Foxhunter models. I don't know if the Chinese version of the Poole models will fit, they may do.

In general, Foxhunter kits were amongst the best for the time, but occasionally there were compromises to fit the chassis available. Body/boiler in white metal, fittings in cast brass.  Some tender sides/top were etched brass, can't remember now.

Martyn
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 12, 2023, 08:46:18 AM
Quote from: martyn on September 12, 2023, 08:10:32 AM
Quote from: Le Night ferry on September 12, 2023, 05:18:25 AM
Quote from: icairns on September 12, 2023, 05:01:27 AMFoxhunter kits are long out of production but they did make a kit for a King 4-6-0 as shown below.  The only way to obtain one now would be on the second-hand market. 

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045526.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135547)

(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/135/3276-120923045610.jpeg) (https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?action=gallery;sa=view&id=135548)

Here is a link to an old thread with some information about Foxhunter from circa 2009:

https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/index.php?topic=45761.msg581661#msg581661

Ian



GF Castle will be old Poole version of it, right?

Yes, the Poole version, as were all the chassis used for different Foxhunter models. I don't know if the Chinese version of the Poole models will fit, they may do.

In general, Foxhunter kits were amongst the best for the time, but occasionally there were compromises to fit the chassis available. Body/boiler in white metal, fittings in cast brass.  Some tender sides/top were etched brass, can't remember now.

Martyn
Sad that they closed business
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: martyn on September 12, 2023, 08:59:51 AM
Yes, in some ways a pity, but it was another 'one man band' making the kits in spare time as his own hobby.

I've built J39, Austerity 2-8-0, and K3 from this range; as well as 12T vans and LNER Fish vans. Whilst some of the kits have now been replaced by models from RTR firms such as Farish, the Foxhunter kit was, I think, the only way, at least at that time (25+years ago) to get a 3500 gallon tender version of the J39.

Martyn

Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bealman on September 12, 2023, 09:10:38 AM
Yes, it was a different world in the early days of British N gauge.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on September 12, 2023, 09:17:00 AM
Quote from: Bealman on September 12, 2023, 09:10:38 AMYes, it was a different world in the early days of British N gauge.
Hard to imagine if there were no Farish in n gauge
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on September 12, 2023, 10:04:22 AM
Quote from: martyn on September 12, 2023, 08:59:51 AMYes, in some ways a pity, but it was another 'one man band' making the kits in spare time as his own hobby.

I've built J39, Austerity 2-8-0, and K3 from this range; as well as 12T vans and LNER Fish vans. Whilst some of the kits have now been replaced by models from RTR firms such as Farish, the Foxhunter kit was, I think, the only way, at least at that time (25+years ago) to get a 3500 gallon tender version of the J39.

Martyn



You were lucky to have a K3, as I understand it the kit was never formally released, every time I asked he was still to complete the instructions.

I do have an A1 built and painted for me by Fred Hempsall years before the Farish one was announced, it is a lovely loco, now kept only for posterity.

I also had the ROD 2-8-0 kit (LNER 04) but that never got started and I ended up giving away what remained in the box many years ago. I have always felt that the loco would make a good RTR project due to the long life, widespread use (including Europe and Australia) and different variants (Swindon built, side-window cabs, Belpaire or round-topped firebox just off the top of my head) lots of liveries, one preserved.

Roy
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: martyn on September 12, 2023, 10:37:56 AM
OFF TOPIC! OFF TOPIC!

Quote from: Roy L S on September 12, 2023, 10:04:22 AM
Quote from: martyn on September 12, 2023, 08:59:51 AMYes, in some ways a pity, but it was another 'one man band' making the kits in spare time as his own hobby.

I've built J39, Austerity 2-8-0, and K3 from this range; as well as 12T vans and LNER Fish vans. Whilst some of the kits have now been replaced by models from RTR firms such as Farish, the Foxhunter kit was, I think, the only way, at least at that time (25+years ago) to get a 3500 gallon tender version of the J39.

Martyn



You were lucky to have a K3, as I understand it the kit was never formally released, every time I asked he was still to complete the instructions.

I do have an A1 built and painted for me by Fred Hempsall years before the Farish one was announced, it is a lovely loco, now kept only for posterity.

I also had the ROD 2-8-0 kit (LNER 04) but that never got started and I ended up giving away what remained in the box many years ago. I have always felt that the loco would make a good RTR project due to the long life, widespread use (including Europe and Australia) and different variants (Swindon built, side-window cabs, Belpaire or round-topped firebox just off the top of my head) lots of liveries, one preserved.

Roy

Yes, I was lucky with the K3. I had met the owner previously at a few shows when exhibiting 'Lynford Junction', and had built the J39/1. I kept pestering about the K3, and the answer was the same as yours; 'I haven't written the instructions'. then at a show where I was a visitor, I met him again, and finally he said 'you have built more than enough kits, if I sell you one it will be without the instructions, but I think you will figure it out'. So he did, and I built it........the kit came with replacement cylinders, as it fitted the Poole 'Crab' chassis; luckily, they went in place first time, to my surprise! However, after traction issues (it was OK, but wouldn't haul as much as I wanted to), I took the Poole motor out of the chassis, and swapped tenders for a Union Mills LNER one. And now it will pull whatever I want. The loco body does sit overheight, though, due to the clearances need to fit the Crab motor. It seems to have been slightly stretched dimension wise vertically.

I built the Austerity later, fitting it with an LNER 8-w Farish tender chassis for improved pick-up; also a number of BR 12T vans (since made by Farish), and a decent set of LNER Fish vans, both sliding and cupboard door versions. The latter can be seen at times on James Street.

I think the cast brass fittings for the K3 were by N-Brass; at least Nick sold/sells a very similar set.

Martyn
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: The Q on September 14, 2023, 04:19:14 PM
The obvious missing 4-6-0 is the first UK one, the Highland Railways, Jones Goods.

The Jones Goods is one I'll eventually make it no one brings one out..
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Fredastaire on November 01, 2026, 01:19:23 PM
(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/162/162735-4372-IMG20261101113919628.jpeg)
.
@Le Night ferry here is a Foxhunter King kit built 2026. I'm well pleased with it! It's built on a China chassis
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 01, 2026, 06:59:16 PM
what was wrong with the farish kings ?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Dorsetmike on November 01, 2026, 08:03:02 PM
Still no RTR Southern 4-6-0s just two kits BHE N15, and Langley S15, an H15 can be made from either of these using a chassis with scale 6' drivers, a Nelson could be hacked from a Scot or Jubilee. Of the Drummond 4-6-0s only the T14 lasted for any length of time, I remember seeing an occasional one, the last one was scrapped in about 1951.
I often wonder who has my old Nelson, it probably found it's way onto Ebay or on sale at a show, I let someone do a refurb  on it and a few other SR locos in exchange for a load of chassis, bodies and other bits  I know an H15 found it's way onto Ebay so assume others did I never saw any or the requested refurbs returned, including a Nelson and Arthur as well as the H15
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on November 03, 2026, 11:55:22 PM
Quote from: Fredastaire on November 01, 2026, 01:19:23 PM(https://www.ngaugeforum.co.uk/SMFN/gallery/162/162735-4372-IMG20261101113919628.jpeg)
.
@Le Night ferry here is a Foxhunter King kit built 2026. I'm well pleased with it! It's built on a China chassis
King edward 2!
One of my favorite locomotive.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Le Night ferry on November 04, 2026, 12:34:51 PM
Dapol had made lots of GWR 4-6-0s, like hall, grange and (older and newer) manor class.
What if they release it-GWR 6000 King George V with its bell.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: PLD on November 04, 2026, 03:25:06 PM
In the last 5 years or so, we've had 3 different proposals for a King seeking expressions of interest.

The only one who shared any information claimed to have reached 30-somthing percent of the numbers needed to be viable; we can assume the others achieved less than that...

That strongly indicates that the supposed demand is not there, just a few albeit rather vocal modellers, unless you can provide irrefutable evidence otherwise...

So for those who state a desire for a King, the question has to be did you submit an expression of interest for any/all of the proposals?; and if not why not?? Was it an aversion to the suppliers, a mistrust in their funding methods, the price point or something else??
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Steven B on November 04, 2026, 04:36:30 PM
DJ Models, KR Models and who else for the King?

Personally, I think it would sell, but then it's not my money being invested (and I might think differently if it were)!
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 04, 2026, 07:56:31 PM
would a retooled King sell ?

weve had 3 incarnations of Hall
3 manors
2 castles
Grange
King----so a new one is long overdue.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: PLD on November 04, 2026, 09:11:20 PM
Quote from: Steven B on November 04, 2026, 04:36:30 PMDJ Models, KR Models and who else for the King?

Personally, I think it would sell, but then it's not my money being invested (and I might think differently if it were)!
I had Hattons in mind, but thinking about it was that a tie-in  with DJ (on one a re-hash of the other)?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: PLD on November 04, 2026, 09:21:45 PM
Quote from: Bigmac on November 04, 2026, 07:56:31 PMwould a retooled King sell ?
As said above, the outcomes of recent calls for expressions of interest (which are the only solid evidence we or potential manufacturers have to go on) would suggest not...

If you (or anyone) wants to persuade a manufacturer otherwise, a lot of evidence to the contrary will be needed...
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Wrinkly1 on November 05, 2026, 07:53:56 AM
I'm one of those who have hesitated. I have many of the other 4-6-0 locos but like most of the steam-based layouts I've seen at shows, my layout is of a modest rural town. The king class were only used on 3 routes (Paddington to Wolverhampton, Plymouth or Bristol) so they don't feature on my wish-list.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Steven B on November 05, 2026, 09:01:05 AM
Quote from: PLD on November 04, 2026, 09:11:20 PMI had Hattons in mind, but thinking about it was that a tie-in  with DJ (on one a re-hash of the other)?

Hattons announced one in OO in September 2014, probably via DJ Models but it was quickly dropped as Hornby released/annouced an updated model not long after.

The Hattons range had about 15 different models in it - with variations of chimney and cab height. I believe neither N Gauge model (DJ and KR) was going to have quite the same level of variation.

Would it sell? I think so - we've seen LMS twins and Deltic from Bachmann, class 41 Warship from EFE and the prototype HSDT from Dapol.

There are big passenger locos for the LNER (several!), LMS and SR so I still think it would sell even if in real life it was route restricted. If nothing else, the inside/outside bearing bogie makes it looks somewhat different to any other GWR 4-6-0.

Compared to say an A4, roughly the same number were built (31 Kings vs 35 A4). The King had a longer life. 1927-62 cf. 1935-66). The A4 wins on number of liveries - four pre-nationalisation (silver, blue, green and war time black) and two BR for the A4 although GWR had variations on tender lettering.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 09:06:25 AM
Quote from: PLD on November 04, 2026, 09:11:20 PM
Quote from: Steven B on November 04, 2026, 04:36:30 PMDJ Models, KR Models and who else for the King?

Personally, I think it would sell, but then it's not my money being invested (and I might think differently if it were)!
I had Hattons in mind, but thinking about it was that a tie-in  with DJ (on one a re-hash of the other)?

No, Hattons were collaborating with DJM for a OO King which didn't come to fruition but there was never an agreement with Hattons for one in N, which is why Dave Jones ended up trying to crowdfund it under the DJM banner himself (and sadly as it never happened a fair few people lost money).

The only N locomotive Hattons ever proposed was the LMS Garratt which was pretty ambitious as a first N project (and only proposed because their OO one did so well which shows a lack of understanding of the N market).

As far as I am aware, the only Kings that have actually been delivered are the Foxhunter kit, and the Farish (Poole) RTR. RTR models were also proposed by DJM and later KR Models (with many saying KR had resurrected the DJM CADS which was denied).

My personal view is that the King would make a nice model and any addition to N is to be welcomed, but against it sadly is very likely (and possibly illogically if no money asked for up front) some people's experience of losing money on the DJM model, plus it's very limited route availability (Double Red) and the reality that the Castle (of which Farish produce a lovely model) could undertake probably 90% of the tasks that would be asked of a King in the real world.

Much more useful (in my opinion) will be the soon to arrive GW Mogul which will then provide a fairly well balanced stud of locos in N with current availability, from 64xx through 57xx, Large Prairie, Mogul, Hall, Castle and a Manor still to come.

Roy
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: port perran on November 05, 2026, 09:12:29 AM
I, for one would love a King.

I have two GF ones, one in blue livery with single chimney, and one in green with a double chimney.

Both run really well but look rather dated so a new version would go down well as would a County to complete my fleet of sea wall 4-6-0s.

Plus, of course, not a 4-6-0 but a 47xx 2-8-0 would be the icing on the cake.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 10:38:38 AM
Couldn't agree more with you Martin.

The GWR/W.R. is said to be the most modelled, so sales potential must be rather high?

I'd hoped for one of those you mention appearing in yesterday's Farish announcement.

I'll buy another Hall when the Hawksworth tender version arrives. Maybe we have to wait for these before anything else GWR/W.R.

I have to wonder how sales have been with the recently released Hall class?
Purchased two and very happy with them.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Newportnobby on November 05, 2026, 10:59:45 AM
Despite a mainly WR bias I've never hankered after a 'King'. I never saw one at Oxford in my spotting days and here's what Google A.I. has to say.......

The 30-strong King class (4-6-0) carried a heavy "Double Red" route classification due to their 22.5-ton axle load (the highest of any British 4-6-0). Because of these strict weight and civil engineering limits, they were generally restricted from routes like the Oxford-to-Worcester (Cotswold) line and standard local turns.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Ensign Elliott on November 05, 2026, 11:09:29 AM
My two top "wants" are a King and a 10xx County.

I don't really hold with the thinking that "the Kings are unsellable because a one man band company tried to produce one and went bankrupt". I'm guessing that there are many people who would like a King and who didn't have anything to do with the previous attempts to make one and certainly didn't put money up front.

Personally I'm a bit old fashioned and avoid these small one man band, crowdfunding things. I prefer to just buy what Farish, Dapol etc release. 

Considering we now have relatively obscure things like D600 Warships of which there were only 5, and Baby Deltics of only 10, I would think that the WR's top express passenger loco of a fleet of 30 would be a good seller, especially with the amount of WR layouts there are out there.

The Kings were around for 35 years and ran Paddington - Plymouth, Wolvs, Bristol etc.. so a good chunk of the WR mainlines. The D600 warships were around for 10 years and spent most of that West of Plymouth...   

If Farish released one tomorrow, I'm sure they'd sell as well as the castles and halls.




Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 11:14:19 AM
Quote from: Newportnobby on November 05, 2026, 10:59:45 AMDespite a mainly WR bias I've never hankered after a 'King'. I never saw one at Oxford in my spotting days and here's what Google A.I. has to say.......

The 30-strong King class (4-6-0) carried a heavy "Double Red" route classification due to their 22.5-ton axle load (the highest of any British 4-6-0). Because of these strict weight and civil engineering limits, they were generally restricted from routes like the Oxford-to-Worcester (Cotswold) line and standard local turns.

I would very much doubt that "standard local turns" would be part of a King's typical rostering, they were used on the heaviest expresses to Birmingham/Wolverhampton Low Level, the Bristol route and West Country as far as Plymouth. Therein lies one issue as a model in N, but as has been said previously (and I have to reflect), it isn't really so different to the A3s.A4s, Duchesses and Merchant Navies...
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: port perran on November 05, 2026, 11:24:52 AM
Quote from: Newportnobby on November 05, 2026, 10:59:45 AMDespite a mainly WR bias I've never hankered after a 'King'. I never saw one at Oxford in my spotting days and here's what Google A.I. has to say.......

The 30-strong King class (4-6-0) carried a heavy "Double Red" route classification due to their 22.5-ton axle load (the highest of any British 4-6-0). Because of these strict weight and civil engineering limits, they were generally restricted from routes like the Oxford-to-Worcester (Cotswold) line and standard local turns.
I doubt one ever made it to Oxford under normal circumstances but very happy to be proven wrong.

However, they did venture onto a branch line regularly.
The Paignton to Kingswear branch saw through workings by Kings with expresses from London (Paddington).

So, anyone modelling Kingswear or Churston as country branch stations or a terminus (or a representation of such stations) can justifiably include a King.

As a young lad growing up in Trowbridge, we always thought that the reason we didn't see Kings there was because their front bogie was too heavy and their cylinders were too wide.
That wasn't of course, the reason but we believed it back then.
I did see Kings at Westbury though.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 11:46:26 AM
Being a Brummie born and grown i saw most of the Kings at Snow hill.

I did ask a few replies back what was wrong with the farish king ?--but no one replied. I have 2--both run well and look good, cost me about £40 each on ebay. I would definitely buy a new tooled one.

I think it could be farish's best seller.

I think farish took a bold step in doing the Hall--after Dapol must have sold stacks of theirs.

Also--the 64xx pannier--why ?

I hope farish do it: i think its too much of a risk for the small players.
Dapol?--no point--i will be long gone before it would put in an appearance.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 12:15:43 PM
Quote from: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 11:46:26 AMBeing a Brummie born and grown i saw most of the Kings at Snow hill.

I did ask a few replies back what was wrong with the farish king ?--but no one replied. I have 2--both run well and look good, cost me about £40 each on ebay. I would definitely buy a new tooled one.

I think it could be farish's best seller.

I think farish took a bold step in doing the Hall--after Dapol must have sold stacks of theirs.

Also--the 64xx pannier--why ?

I hope farish do it: i think its too much of a risk for the small players.
Dapol?--no point--i will be long gone before it would put in an appearance.

What is wrong with the last Farish King? Well even at the time it wasn't the best of models, borrowing a Castle chassis to keep costs down.

In terms of now, the simple answer is what was originally produced back in the late 1990s no longer meets expectations, things have moved on, people now expect a more accurate chassis with see-through spokes and underframe detail, accurate well detailed body with separate handrails/fittings, glazed and detailed cab, DCC socket and speaker.

The Hall was a good choice because the Dapol one was showing it's age, and this latest Farish one is to modern standards. A mixed traffic loco like that is extremely versatile and travelled far and wide, they even found their way onto the Great Central on cross-country expresses as far as Leicester and on occasions Nottingham - which is why I have a couple of them, I would have no place for a King or Castle but ba Hall yes, ditto the soon to be released Dapol GW mogul.

I suspect the 64xx came into being because (1) they do one in OO (2) it makes a good partner for their Hawksworth auto-coach and (3) at the time Dapol were already producing the 57xx (and still do today). It isn't a bad choice, predominately a branch-line loco I believe they were also used on main line push-pull turns on occasion.

As to a "King" being a "best seller" I think that is doubtful as there are many more versatile classes of GW loco of which the Hall and Castle are two, the fact that Bachmann have done a second run of Castles says a lot.

Might a "King" nonetheless "wash it's face" financially? That is probably a more realistic prospect, it is certainly appears more likely to than the air-smoothed "Merchant Navy" Farish produced (which didn't seem to sell well).

Roy
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Newportnobby on November 05, 2026, 12:23:09 PM
Quote from: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 11:14:19 AM
Quote from: Newportnobby on November 05, 2026, 10:59:45 AMDespite a mainly WR bias I've never hankered after a 'King'. I never saw one at Oxford in my spotting days and here's what Google A.I. has to say.......

The 30-strong King class (4-6-0) carried a heavy "Double Red" route classification due to their 22.5-ton axle load (the highest of any British 4-6-0). Because of these strict weight and civil engineering limits, they were generally restricted from routes like the Oxford-to-Worcester (Cotswold) line and standard local turns.

I would very much doubt that "standard local turns" would be part of a King's typical rostering

I think that's typical A.I. ambiguity, Roy. I took it to mean the Kings were banned from Oxford-Worcester and standard local turns.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 12:35:31 PM
Quote from: Newportnobby on November 05, 2026, 12:23:09 PM
Quote from: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 11:14:19 AM
Quote from: Newportnobby on November 05, 2026, 10:59:45 AMDespite a mainly WR bias I've never hankered after a 'King'. I never saw one at Oxford in my spotting days and here's what Google A.I. has to say.......

The 30-strong King class (4-6-0) carried a heavy "Double Red" route classification due to their 22.5-ton axle load (the highest of any British 4-6-0). Because of these strict weight and civil engineering limits, they were generally restricted from routes like the Oxford-to-Worcester (Cotswold) line and standard local turns.

I would very much doubt that "standard local turns" would be part of a King's typical rostering

I think that's typical A.I. ambiguity, Roy. I took it to mean the Kings were banned from Oxford-Worcester and standard local turns.

Yes I now see that, and to think AI is supposedly the future (or so the Tech giants and politicians would have us believe!).
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 01:43:33 PM
consider the big four:

Eastern have had numerous streaks from several manufacturers for many years

LM :Duchess locos by farish--poole, early China and the superb coreless masterpiece  ( but no princess--but thats a different story )

Southern: several WC/BB and MN both streamlined and not---and a new tool by Dapol definitely imminent anytime soon eventually.

So--why not a new King? after all--we have The New King already.

So--come on guys--no more negative replies--dont give Farish the wrong idea.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: thebrighton on November 05, 2026, 01:52:14 PM
Is it because all GWR tender locos look the same so no one knows if it's a King or not  :D
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 01:59:58 PM
Quote from: thebrighton on November 05, 2026, 01:52:14 PMIs it because all GWR tender locos look the same so no one knows if it's a King or not  :D

no they dont !!!  The King driving wheels are 2" smaller than the Castle---thats very important in N gauge.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: martyn on November 05, 2026, 02:17:55 PM
Sorry, but 2" difference in driving wheel diameter wasn't even important at 12" : 1'.

Tyre wear could mean that drivers could be up to three inches smaller than nominal diameter before replacement was needed; it varied from company to company, probably, but I'm not sure.

So you could have a King with worn tyres with smaller wheels then a newly tyred Castle.

The biggest noticeable differences between King and Castle were front bogie and main steam pipe layout.

I've nothing against a King, but they certainly never got to East Anglia  ;) . Though as has just been said, the LNER Pacifics and V2s are available, and they were basically ECML and associated loops or GCR (not A4s) for their working lives.

Martyn

 

Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 02:30:16 PM
 "Sorry, but 2" difference in driving wheel diameter wasn't even important at 12" : 1'."


errm--i was being facetious  ;D
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 02:36:38 PM
Quote from: martyn on November 05, 2026, 02:17:55 PMSorry, but 2" difference in driving wheel diameter wasn't even important at 12" : 1'.

Tyre wear could mean that drivers could be up to three inches smaller than nominal diameter before replacement was needed; it varied from company to company, probably, but I'm not sure.

So you could have a King with worn tyres with smaller wheels then a newly tyred Castle.

The biggest noticeable differences between King and Castle were front bogie and main steam pipe layout.

I've nothing against a King, but they certainly never got to East Anglia  ;) . Though as has just been said, the LNER Pacifics and V2s are available, and they were basically ECML and associated loops or GCR (not A4s) for their working lives.

Martyn

The King has a larger boiler both in terms of diameter and length (over 1ft longer) and the firebox is also 1ft 6 ins longer than that of the Castle all of which for me gives it a greater "presence".
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: martyn on November 05, 2026, 03:12:30 PM
To go back to @Dorsetmike OP; the SR has no 4-6-0s, which it relied on for much of its existence for  passenger, and a lesser extent, mixed traffic and goods services. And if the SECR C class was thought viable, why not an SR 4-6-0?

Don't forget that in rtr, with the demise of UM, the LNER only now has two models, the B17 and B1; the latter were only multiplied after WW2, and most were built by BR.

@Bigmac

Sorry, the humour went over my head....

Martyn
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 06:15:48 PM
Quote from: martyn on November 05, 2026, 03:12:30 PMTo go back to @Dorsetmike OP; the SR has no 4-6-0s, which it relied on for much of its existence for  passenger, and a lesser extent, mixed traffic and goods services. And if the SECR C class was thought viable, why not an SR 4-6-0?

Don't forget that in rtr, with the demise of UM, the LNER only now has two models, the B17 and B1; the latter were only multiplied after WW2, and most were built by BR.

@Bigmac

Sorry, the humour went over my head....

Martyn

Re the C Class: Maybe there was a tie up between Bachman and the Bluebell, sponsorship perhaps, otherwise it was a strange choice for n gauge. Was it a good seller ?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: thebrighton on November 05, 2026, 06:22:58 PM
Quote from: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 06:15:48 PMRe the C Class: Maybe there was a tie up between Bachman and the Bluebell, sponsorship perhaps, otherwise it was a strange choice for n gauge. Was it a good seller ?

Well they released a second run so I would say yes.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 07:18:54 PM
I paid two deposits with D.J. for Kings.

Paying by credit card I had the deposits repaid in full. I know others were not so lucky in getting their money back, if they paid by a different way.

I think the most likely to release a King would be Farish.

Dapol have dropped their controversial cardan shaft. I imagine many will be keen to see/try their Mogul and Manor with the new mechanisms. (I wonder who was responsible for the cardan shaft at Dapol?) A Grange with their new mechanism could be next from them?

Sonic could surprise us with a King. I understand their owner once worked for Bachmann, and designed the latest incarnation of the Coronation/Duchess loco.

Any of them may/or may not be working on a King in the background.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 08:12:02 PM
Quote from: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 06:15:48 PMRe the C Class: Maybe there was a tie up between Bachman and the Bluebell, sponsorship perhaps, otherwise it was a strange choice for n gauge. Was it a good seller ?

The C Class was part of their OO range, I don't think one needs to look any further than that for the reason it then became part of the Farish range along with the SECR "Birdcage" coaches. The loco is exquisite and included features never seen in a British outline 0-6-0 tender loco up to that point such as Next 18 socket and speaker. The ones in the intricate SE&CR livery sold out pretty quickly and there is nothing to suggest the loco was in anything but a success, with the likes of me (with no interest in matters "Southern") buying one just because it is such a lovely model, mine now being fitted with a sound chip.

As @thebrighton rightly points out, the fact there has recently been a second run including a "Collectors club" special and this time including a sound fitted option points to the first batch being popular otherwise they wouldn't have done it.

Roy
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: PLD on November 05, 2026, 09:58:44 PM
Quote from: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 07:18:54 PMDapol have dropped their controversial cardan shaft. ... ... ... (I wonder who was responsible for the cardan shaft at Dapol?)

Quote from: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 07:18:54 PMI paid two deposits with D.J. for Kings.
The very same DJ was Product Designer at Dapol through most of that period...
It was amusing that as soon as he parted ways with dapol, some of his most vocal supporters slated the very designs he was responsible for!

Theres nothing inherently wrong with the principle of the motor in the tender with a cardan shaft driving the loco wheels - it's the flavoured layout for 2mm finescale locos; just that to make it so locos would go around train-set corners, Dapols design had to have sufficient 'slop' in it that with rough handling the shafts were liable to pop out of the sockets.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: tunneroner61 on November 05, 2026, 11:52:11 PM
Please corect me if I'm wrong, but I am under the impression that Dapol inherited the cardan shaft design concept from Ixion when Dapol took on the Manor. I have an Ixion Manor and for smoothness and quietness it is far far better than the Dapol tender locos I have. It goes round 9" radius curves too. As has been pointed out previously I do suspect Dapol 'cost engineered' the whole power train design concept downwards.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Steven B on November 06, 2026, 09:15:36 AM
Stepping away from the King and other 4-6-0s, it's interesting to look at the smaller tender engines.

The C Class is an exceptional little loco, and handily fills the 0-6-0 tender loco shaped gap in the SR fleet.

LMS has the Fowler, LNER the J39 leaving GWR fans to hunt for long discontinued Peco 2251s if they want an 0-6-0 tender loco.

I feel it's the 4-4-0s that are noticeable by their absence. With the loss of the Union Mill Dukedog, I think there's only the Dapol Schools.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Roy L S on November 06, 2026, 10:35:34 AM
Quote from: tunneroner61 on November 05, 2026, 11:52:11 PMPlease corect me if I'm wrong, but I am under the impression that Dapol inherited the cardan shaft design concept from Ixion when Dapol took on the Manor. I have an Ixion Manor and for smoothness and quietness it is far far better than the Dapol tender locos I have. It goes round 9" radius curves too. As has been pointed out previously I do suspect Dapol 'cost engineered' the whole power train design concept downwards.

It is a while back now but I don't think that is how it came about. I recall that the first Dapol loco to use the cardan shaft arrangement (and their first tender loco) was the Q1 released in 2007.

The Ixion Manor came along later in around 2010 and while it was manufactured for Ixion via Dapol, the design was the work of well respected Australian N modeller Phil Badger rather than anyone at Dapol. 1,200 Ixion Manors were produced in four liveries, I still have my BR black "Hook Norton Manor" to this day.

When Ixion exited from N Gauge following the Manor, Dapol did though take over the tooling and produce the loco themselves, albeit with a different DCC ready tender.

Roy
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: PLD on November 06, 2026, 10:42:44 AM
Quote from: tunneroner61 on November 05, 2026, 11:52:11 PMPlease corect me if I'm wrong, but I am under the impression that Dapol inherited the cardan shaft design concept from Ixion when Dapol took on the Manor.
Can't recall exact dates for all, but Dapol had certainly released at least the Q1, 9F (both around 2007/8 ish), Britania (2009) and possibly also the LNER B17 & B1 with the same drive layout, prior to the Ixion Manor being produced in early 2010 (passing to Dapol late 2011)...

It was noted at the time the similarities in the set-up, and there was some debate who was primarily responsible for the design of the Manor mechanism.
Dapol certainly did it first but did Ixion copy Dapol? did Dapol impose their design on Ixion? or did they independently arrive at the same solution?
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Newportnobby on November 06, 2026, 11:00:39 AM
Quote from: Roy L S on November 05, 2026, 08:12:02 PM
Quote from: Bigmac on November 05, 2026, 06:15:48 PMRe the C Class: Maybe there was a tie up between Bachman and the Bluebell, sponsorship perhaps, otherwise it was a strange choice for n gauge. Was it a good seller ?

The C Class was part of their OO range, I don't think one needs to look any further than that for the reason it then became part of the Farish range along with the SECR "Birdcage" coaches. The loco is exquisite and included features never seen in a British outline 0-6-0 tender loco up to that point such as Next 18 socket and speaker. The ones in the intricate SE&CR livery sold out pretty quickly and there is nothing to suggest the loco was in anything but a success, with the likes of me (with no interest in matters "Southern") buying one just because it is such a lovely model, mine now being fitted with a sound chip.

As @thebrighton rightly points out, the fact there has recently been a second run including a "Collectors club" special and this time including a sound fitted option points to the first batch being popular otherwise they wouldn't have done it.

Roy

I'm the proud owner of 3 x C class locos, 2 of which are in the SECR livery. Farish chimed in with their lovely 'birdcage' stock and Dapol had their exquisite little 'Terrier' in SECR and that's probably the most popular in that range. Rapido then added a lovely range of SECR wagons.
However, back on the 4-6-0 subject, I would love to see a SR loco as they were oft seen at Oxford so an S15, 'King Arthur' or 'Lord Nelson' would be a very nice addition to my Bulleids, M7, Schools and N class :)
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Dorsetmike on November 06, 2026, 02:11:56 PM
to quote StevenB

"There are big passenger locos for the LNER (several!), LMS and SR so I still think it would sell even if in real life it was route restricted. If nothing else, the inside/outside bearing bogie makes it looks somewhat different to any other GWR 4-6-0."

The only SR 4-6-0s are the Langley and BHE white metal kits, the only "big" SR passenger locos available in N gauge are the Bullied  4-6-2s which did not appear until the 1940s, the only "express passenger" loco prior to 1940 modeled in N is the Schools 4-4-0.
At grouping the SR got the 3 classes of 4-6-0 by Urie H15, N15 & S15 plus a few remaining Drummonds, Maunsell continued some of the Urie classes with a few modifications and introduced the Nelson in 1926.
The 3 classes of Urie 4-6-0s were almost identical except for driving wheel diameter, so all 3 classes could use the same basic body and a basic chassis available with 5'7", 6'0" or 6'7" wheels spaced correctly for the class; The same chassis  could probably suit Maunsell versions of the 3 classes, a few minor alterations to body e.g. cabs (mainly roof) 
Having played mix 'n match and hack with the Langley and BHE kits over the years if I can do it why can't a manufacturer with vastly more facilities????
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 06, 2026, 02:19:06 PM
Quote from: Dorsetmike on November 06, 2026, 02:11:56 PMto quote StevenB

"There are big passenger locos for the LNER (several!), LMS and SR so I still think it would sell even if in real life it was route restricted. If nothing else, the inside/outside bearing bogie makes it looks somewhat different to any other GWR 4-6-0."

The only SR 4-6-0s are the Langley and BHE white metal kits, the only "big" SR passenger locos available in N gauge are the Bullied  4-6-2s which did not appear until the 1940s, the only "express passenger" loco prior to 1940 modeled in N is the Schools 4-4-0.
At grouping the SR got the 3 classes of 4-6-0 by Urie H15, N15 & S15 plus a few remaining Drummonds, Maunsell continued some of the Urie classes with a few modifications and introduced the Nelson in 1926.
The 3 classes of Urie 4-6-0s were almost identical except for driving wheel diameter, so all 3 classes could use the same basic body and a basic chassis available with 5'7", 6'0" or 6'7" wheels spaced correctly for the class; The same chassis  could probably suit Maunsell versions of the 3 classes, a few minor alterations to body e.g. cabs (mainly roof) 
Having played mix 'n match and hack with the Langley and BHE kits over the years if I can do it why can't a manufacturer with vastly more facilities????



Please note--Gosport Railworks ( JimSan ) offer 3d printed bodies for several Southern 4-6-0's: although ive yet to do any.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Jollybob on November 06, 2026, 02:35:38 PM
I don't really want to buy any more locomotives, the cost of them just put me off. That being said, i would throw my weight to support the other guys here saying that a 4-6-0 from the southern is well needed. A mixed traffic loco like the S15 perhaps? They did get around a lot on the Britains rail network.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: leachsprite4 on November 06, 2026, 10:40:03 PM
Quote from: Dorsetmike on November 06, 2026, 02:11:56 PMto quote StevenB

"There are big passenger locos for the LNER (several!), LMS and SR so I still think it would sell even if in real life it was route restricted. If nothing else, the inside/outside bearing bogie makes it looks somewhat different to any other GWR 4-6-0."

The only SR 4-6-0s are the Langley and BHE white metal kits, the only "big" SR passenger locos available in N gauge are the Bullied  4-6-2s which did not appear until the 1940s, the only "express passenger" loco prior to 1940 modeled in N is the Schools 4-4-0.
At grouping the SR got the 3 classes of 4-6-0 by Urie H15, N15 & S15 plus a few remaining Drummonds, Maunsell continued some of the Urie classes with a few modifications and introduced the Nelson in 1926.
The 3 classes of Urie 4-6-0s were almost identical except for driving wheel diameter, so all 3 classes could use the same basic body and a basic chassis available with 5'7", 6'0" or 6'7" wheels spaced correctly for the class; The same chassis  could probably suit Maunsell versions of the 3 classes, a few minor alterations to body e.g. cabs (mainly roof) 
Having played mix 'n match and hack with the Langley and BHE kits over the years if I can do it why can't a manufacturer with vastly more facilities????

Sad face from me as I am also waiting for Southern 4-6-0
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: tunneroner61 on November 06, 2026, 11:02:29 PM
@PLD and @Roy L S . Thanks for the corrections to my post. I wasn't into steam at the time of Dapol and Ixion bringing out their steam locos so have probably got a bit confused.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Dorsetmike on November 06, 2026, 11:39:04 PM
RE the SR N15 and S15 kits, The Langley S15 on the Fleischmann chassis is OK, the BHE N15 using the suggested Black 5 chassis is not, the chassis driving heels are too small a Jubilee or Scot would be closer. For an H15 you need 6' drivers.
Between them the two kits can be hacked to the SR 4-6-0s of classes H15, N15 and S15 (but not the Nelson) for Maunsell versions the cab roof is he main change, Smoke deflectors were not fitted from new on the Urie versions until after grouping AFAIK.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: elmo on November 08, 2026, 07:01:22 AM
Quote from: PLD on November 05, 2026, 09:58:44 PM
Quote from: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 07:18:54 PMDapol have dropped their controversial cardan shaft. ... ... ... (I wonder who was responsible for the cardan shaft at Dapol?)

Quote from: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 07:18:54 PMI paid two deposits with D.J. for Kings.
The very same DJ was Product Designer at Dapol through most of that period...
It was amusing that as soon as he parted ways with dapol, some of his most vocal supporters slated the very designs he was responsible for!

Theres nothing inherently wrong with the principle of the motor in the tender with a cardan shaft driving the loco wheels - it's the flavoured layout for 2mm finescale locos; just that to make it so locos would go around train-set corners, Dapols design had to have sufficient 'slop' in it that with rough handling the shafts were liable to pop out of the sockets.

At a toy fair a few years ago I saw an o gauge Merchant Navy running  a train of Pullmans using a cardan shaft. It is not than many years ago in the big scheme of things that the smallest motor available did not fit a locomotive body but could be squeezed into the tender. I do not personally mind tender motors or tender drive so long as the locomotives wheels are free to run. My first n gauge locomotive was the Lima 4F tender drive. People without model railway knowledge never knew the tender was doing the work until I pointed it out to them.
Title: Re: 4-6-0 thread
Post by: Bigmac on November 08, 2026, 07:54:56 AM
Quote from: elmo on November 08, 2026, 07:01:22 AM
Quote from: PLD on November 05, 2026, 09:58:44 PM
Quote from: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 07:18:54 PMDapol have dropped their controversial cardan shaft. ... ... ... (I wonder who was responsible for the cardan shaft at Dapol?)

Quote from: trkilliman on November 05, 2026, 07:18:54 PMI paid two deposits with D.J. for Kings.
The very same DJ was Product Designer at Dapol through most of that period...
It was amusing that as soon as he parted ways with dapol, some of his most vocal supporters slated the very designs he was responsible for!

Theres nothing inherently wrong with the principle of the motor in the tender with a cardan shaft driving the loco wheels - it's the flavoured layout for 2mm finescale locos; just that to make it so locos would go around train-set corners, Dapols design had to have sufficient 'slop' in it that with rough handling the shafts were liable to pop out of the sockets.

At a toy fair a few years ago I saw an o gauge Merchant Navy running  a train of Pullmans using a cardan shaft. It is not than many years ago in the big scheme of things that the smallest motor available did not fit a locomotive body but could be squeezed into the tender. I do not personally mind tender motors or tender drive so long as the locomotives wheels are free to run. My first n gauge locomotive was the Lima 4F tender drive. People without model railway knowledge never knew the tender was doing the work until I pointed it out to them.

I think the first motor in tender with shaft drive into loco was the Arnold P4, 4-4-0 . I had one, about 40 years ago .