N Gauge Forum

General Category => N Gauge Discussion => Topic started by: Intercity on January 02, 2018, 11:16:45 PM

Title: wagons...choices
Post by: Intercity on January 02, 2018, 11:16:45 PM
I am about to start filling out the rolling stock library with some wagons, however I have a couple of questions first.

Farish have HAAs and HEAs, am I right in thinking both transported coal? but the HAA was for Merry Go Round service and HEAs didn't have that capability?

The MBAs are the Megabox bogie wagons, did these only operate in formations solely comprised of MBAs?

OCAs are the 31 tonne dropside wagons, are these ideal for a civil engineers train (which other wagons would be found in these consists?

as for Dapol, the silver bullets are nice but what service were they used for?

Grampus wagons are freely available, what sort of use did they see?

JNAs and IOAs are really nice looking, are these mixed in with other wagons and would I only see them on ballast workings?

I remember there were others I would see in various sidings but don't really remember the details, guessing lengths varied by work intended to be done (but what would be typical for a model layout)

I am modeling early 90s through to the 2000s with large amounts of rule one.

IC
Title: Re: wagons...choices
Post by: bridgiesimon on January 02, 2018, 11:24:07 PM
HBA/HEA wagons were designed for shorter and domestic coal flows not power stations as you mention, some also used for calcified seaweed in Cornwall if I remember correctly!
OCAs not only engineers but for general goods as well, many used for military stuff as well, I have seen wagons like these used for landrovers etc somewhere.

Silver Bullets are for china clay slurry and mainly ran in block rkes but could be seen individually and in pairs etc in mixed freight trains as well.

Grampus are engineers wagons, used for ballast mainly.
no idea on the JNA and IOA but piccies seem to suggest formations of one wagon type, am sure others will confirm either way.

Hope this is a start.

Best wishes
Simon
Title: Re: wagons...choices
Post by: Snowwolflair on January 02, 2018, 11:35:25 PM
Quote from: Arrachogaidh on January 02, 2018, 11:28:30 PM
Silver Bullets run up to Aberdeen with some type of slurry for the oil industry.



Drilling mud

"In geotechnical engineering, drilling fluid is used to aid the drilling of boreholes into the earth. Often used while drilling oil and natural gas wells and on exploration drilling rigs,"
Title: Re: wagons...choices
Post by: bluedepot on January 03, 2018, 01:53:31 AM
Where is this rolling stock library?

HAA bottom discharging and done mechanically at the power station

I think some used for gypsum too

Some HEA later used for scrap metal and coded HSA

Some HEA used for gravel more recently


Tim
Title: Re: wagons...choices
Post by: njee20 on January 03, 2018, 08:31:54 AM
If you model present day (or last 10 years), which I think you do... then HEAs and to an extent HAAs are a bit out of date. More common were HTA (EWS) and HHA (Freightliner) for coal traffic, both bogie wagons.

MBAs tend to be homogeneous rakes, MOAs, the low sided versions are more mixed up. IOAs are used in homogeneous rakes, whilst JNAs are mixed, often used with MOAs.

Silver Bullets are lovely models, particularly the weathered ones.

Obvious missing ones are some Intermodal wagons, which is what dominates the WCML freight traffic. FEAs (GBRF/Freightliner), IKAs (FL/DRS/EWS), FIAs (EWS) all spring to mind. Mixed up within each operator's stock, and available from Dapol/Dapol/Farish respectively. 
Title: Re: wagons...choices
Post by: Buzzard on January 03, 2018, 09:01:55 AM
Quote from: bluedepot on January 03, 2018, 01:53:31 AMI think some used for gypsum too

The gypsum ones that used to run on the Southern were HAA lookalikes in that

they were built to the pre-1986 Hastings line gauge
they had different discharge mechanisms and
were coded PGA
Title: Re: wagons...choices
Post by: GScaleBruce on January 04, 2018, 10:55:13 PM
With few exceptions, you only need a brake van if the freight train is not fitted with a continuous air or vacuum brake. You're modelling early 90s to 2000s, by which time unfitted trains only operated under special permission. In simple model terms, if the train is made up of wagons with a description ending in an A, then it'll be fully air baked (a rake of HAAs,  a mixed Speedlink service of OBAs, VBAs,  etc...). If they all end in a V, then they're all vacuum braked, so again no brake van needed. If it's a mix, you'll need a brake van as the two systems are incompatible and part of the train at least wouldn't have a continuous brake operational. Brake vans were often used on engineering trains because the locomotive might be detached during engineering works with a portion of the train parked on the track. A brake van ensures that if and when the air or vacuum brake leaks off, the wagons will be held in place by the brake van.